“Limited” Mode: how the right to make a mistake once saved the world (and why we are obliged to bring it back)

Have you ever wondered why the vast majority of people prefer to sit quietly in an office from 9 to 6, instead of starting their own business, trying to change the world, or even just loudly expressing their opinion? The answer is very simple – it’s all about fear. A primal fear of catastrophic consequences. The fear of losing your apartment due to a failed startup, the fear of falling out of favor with those in power, the fear of ending up on the street with a black mark against your name because of a single careless word.

Without the right to make mistakes, society turns into a paralyzed herd where any initiative is punishable by execution (or, well, lifelong debt). And to understand how to get out of this, let’s remember how humanity once solved this problem.

Do you know where limited liability companies (those very LLCs and LTDs) actually came from? Do you think the monarchs and lords of the past century suddenly developed a love for commoners and decided to show them mercy? Not at all. Before the emergence of this concept, business was a game of Russian roulette. A ship carrying your cargo sank? Welcome to the debt pit. Couldn’t pay off your creditors? Sell your last pair of pants, or even your freedom. Naturally, people hid their money under mattresses in terror. No one wanted to risk their head for the sake of innovation.

And then, gritting their teeth, states realized: if risks are not limited, there simply will be no economy. They decided to make it so that if your business fails, you only lose what you invested in the charter capital. Your house, wife, children, and dog remain yours. This was not an act of kindness, but a cold calculation: people breathed a sigh of relief, pulled out their savings, and the Industrial Revolution began.

And now, look at what is happening today. The state, intoxicated by a thirst for control and tax collection, is methodically destroying the very essence of “limited liability.” The curse of modern business is so-called subsidiary liability. The tax authorities or creditors can easily come after an entrepreneur’s personal property. Underpaid taxes because a counterparty turned out to be a fraud? Hand over your car, your apartment, and we’ll even freeze your grandmother’s accounts.

What does this lead to? Certainly not to prosperity. Sensible people do not want to try doing anything under such conditions. Business goes deep into the shadows, operating in cash, through crypto, registering companies to “drop” homeless people, or simply closing down. People refuse to create because the price of error has once again become fatal.

But let’s go further. Currently, we live in two worlds – the physical and the digital. And while in business they try to deprive us of protection, in the Internet, there was none to begin with. Today, the Web is a minefield with unlimited liability. You wrote the wrong comment, reposted a meme, or argued with the wrong person on a forum – and suddenly, someone is knocking on your real-life door. Imagine you are playing a video game where your character’s death means you lose a finger in real life. How many people would want to play? Exactly.

To liberate the network, it is vital that we transfer the concept of limited liability online. Following the principle: “What happens in Vegas, stays in Vegas.” What is said and done online (within the scope of network activity, exchange of opinions, and virtual interactions) must stay online!

Conservatives, of course, will howl that this will lead to anarchy online and everyone will hide behind masks. But in reality, the exact opposite will happen. People obsessively hide their identities, use double VPNs, and invent nicknames precisely because they fear real-world physical consequences.

If a person knows for a fact that the maximum they risk for their words online is a platform ban, a loss of virtual rating, or a digital block within a specific community, they will relax. They will no longer need to hide. Users will begin to voluntarily and actively reveal their identities because building a real reputation is profitable. A true economy of trust will emerge.

Voluntarist, Bitarch

Why human rights papers aren’t working anymore and how to make them respected again

Recently, Maxim Kats released a video about Davos and the sunset of the “long world.” And you know, there he voiced a thought that makes any normal person (and especially a libertarian) start to feel their hair stand on end. Of course, Maxim isn’t our ally by virtue of his political views, but he still knows how to effectively dissect current problems, so we’ll be considering his reasoning nonetheless. Because he rightly observes: what we call “human rights” – it’s essentially a system error, an anomaly.

His video begins with pointing out that war has long since ceased being just a slaughter between soldiers—scientific and technological progress has reached the point where it’s possible to erase entire cities from the face of the Earth. The idea that humanity could simply self-destruct as a result of another war has stopped being fantastic and has taken on the form of a real risk. Political elites who had experienced World War II realized: we won’t drag out another round. The response was the creation of so-called “international law” and the concept of “human rights,” simply to avoid dying. It was, essentially, a global non-aggression pact signed with a trembling hand at one’s temple.

Of course, international law is largely just a “fiction,” but to some extent states are still willing to play by the established rules and observe restrictions, so this fiction is quite useful. Politicians, naturally, don’t care about the lives of ordinary people and humanitarian ideals, but they are afraid for their own skins anyway, so they won’t go completely overboard. At least that’s how it worked until recently…

But what changed? To power came a generation of politicians who hadn’t personally witnessed disasters or felt the threat of war themselves. They no longer fear mutual guaranteed destruction (MAD) and other scenarios of “deterrence doctrine” so much. For them, all this is just an abstraction from historical textbooks. And therefore, their motivation to observe the “fiction” agreed upon by previous generations of politicians has decreased significantly. As a result, the world once again faces a state of war between everyone and everyone.

Однако несмотря на эти рассуждения, всё же может оставаться вопрос того, насколько реальной является угроза самоуничтожения человечества с технической точки зрения. Кто-то сразу подумает о ядерных боеголовках, но их не так уж много и находятся они в руках очень ограниченного числа лиц (хотя и они могут отбросить человечество на многие десятилетия назад). Впрочем, сейчас технологии зашли ещё дальше. Например, в ближайшем десятилетии мы вполне можем ожидать появление массовых, простых и очень дешёвых в производстве боевых дронов, которые будут иметь автономное управление на основе ИИ и смогут поражать любых «неугодных» людей, включая политиков, используя распознавание лиц, а глушение сигнала окажется неэффективным из-за отсутствия канала связи с оператором. Ещё одна угроза – создание смертоносных и очень заразных искусственных патогенов с целью применения в качестве биологического оружия массового поражения. Биотехнологии уже сейчас довольно продвинуты и дешёвы, чтобы такое было достижимым даже для небольших групп людей, преследующих насильственные политические цели.

В таких условиях в мейнстримовую повестку не просто вернётся значимость универсальных прав человека, гуманизма и идей о недопустимости насилия, а перестанут быть маргинальными и более радикальные способы предотвращения глобальной катастрофы. Идеи наподобие усиления механизма ингибирования насилия и даже морального улучшения людей с помощью биомедицинских технологий (биоусиление морали) уже не будут восприниматься как что-то невозможное или нежелательное для реальной жизни. Развитие этого направления становится необходимостью для долгосрочного искоренения насильственных угроз как в личной, так и общественной жизни. Иначе, как отмечают исследователи, нас ждёт либо глобальный тоталитаризм с круглосуточной слежкой за каждым, либо вовсе уничтожение цивилизации и даже всего человечества.


Не ИИ – пост написан людьми!