Sam Altman’s Cheat Code: How to sell freedom to officials under the guise of “national security”

Recently, a real ideological bomb went off in the US judicial system, which could help the advancement of libertarian ideas. The New York Times filed a lawsuit, complaining that OpenAI dared to train its neural networks on their texts without permission or paid licenses. It seemed like a routine story; the judges in robes should have simply dragged the business under the copyright broom, as they have always done.

But in this case, the US Department of Justice reacted and filed an official statement in support of OpenAI. As stated, legal norms that significantly hinder the development of a sustainable AI industry in the United States threaten national security and give a competitive advantage to foreign adversaries. To translate from bureaucratic to human: if China doesn’t give a damn about licenses and trains its models on everything in sight, then stifling our own tech companies at the request of copyright holders will only lead to us being crushed.

Let’s appreciate the beauty of this historical moment. For decades, libertarians have been saying that so-called “intellectual property,” patents, and copyright are not sacred private property, but an artificial feudal privilege—a bureaucratic charter from a stationary bandit that stifles innovation and sells thin air. And suddenly, the bandit himself realized: his favorite noose for entrepreneurs has turned into a loop around his own neck.

No one in their right mind would call Sam Altman a free-marketer—he loves negotiating with offices and raking in subsidies. But he has accidentally shown us an excellent bug in the state’s operating system, which it is time for libertarians to adopt. Let’s call it the “national security maneuver” and see how this political technology elegantly mows down any restrictions.

Let’s start with taxes and levies. It’s time to stop whining that it’s robbery. It’s better to play the trump card: high taxes are pure sabotage in favor of geopolitical rivals! Capital and investors are packing their bags for the UAE and Hong Kong, which means with what money will we deploy computing clusters and defense plants tomorrow?

The same applies to the medical bureaucracy (the FDA and its analogues in other countries). If they marinate the certification of drugs, vaccines, and genetic engineering for ten years, they are thereby jeopardizing the nation’s survival in the face of the enemy’s biological weapons!

Or perhaps the prohibitionists want to disarm citizens again? However, in an era of hybrid conflicts, a people armed to the teeth is a free, distributed, and indestructible territorial defense army. Look at the Swiss: a gun in every home turns any foreign intervention into hell. Distributing automatic weapons without paperwork only strengthens sovereignty!

And what about immigration barriers? Keeping foreign engineers, mathematicians, and scientists in visa queues for years is a gift to our enemies. We must suck up brains from all over the world like an industrial vacuum cleaner. Any unpleasant specialist will be building missiles for a foreign army tomorrow. Therefore, opening the borders to qualified personnel is a matter of defense capability!

One could even recall speed limits. Think it’s an exaggeration? But watch closely: speed limits on highways of 60–90 km/h artificially slow down logistics, steal millions of working hours, and keep drivers in stress. And chronic stress is proven to kill testosterone, causing the birth rate to plummet. The question is: where does the draft office intend to get soldiers, drone operators, and engineers from in twenty years? This means a speed limit on an empty highway is a direct undermining of demographic and mobilization potential!

It sounds cynical. But what difference does it make what sauce we use to break through the bars of the regulatory pen, if the result is an expansion of real freedom of action? A stationary bandit will never surrender its powers out of respect for our treatises. But it will gladly trample over copyright, levies, and licenses if it sincerely believes that otherwise, a competitor will devour it.

Voluntarist, Bitarch

“Limited” Mode: how the right to make a mistake once saved the world (and why we are obliged to bring it back)

Have you ever wondered why the vast majority of people prefer to sit quietly in an office from 9 to 6, instead of starting their own business, trying to change the world, or even just loudly expressing their opinion? The answer is very simple – it’s all about fear. A primal fear of catastrophic consequences. The fear of losing your apartment due to a failed startup, the fear of falling out of favor with those in power, the fear of ending up on the street with a black mark against your name because of a single careless word.

Without the right to make mistakes, society turns into a paralyzed herd where any initiative is punishable by execution (or, well, lifelong debt). And to understand how to get out of this, let’s remember how humanity once solved this problem.

Do you know where limited liability companies (those very LLCs and LTDs) actually came from? Do you think the monarchs and lords of the past century suddenly developed a love for commoners and decided to show them mercy? Not at all. Before the emergence of this concept, business was a game of Russian roulette. A ship carrying your cargo sank? Welcome to the debt pit. Couldn’t pay off your creditors? Sell your last pair of pants, or even your freedom. Naturally, people hid their money under mattresses in terror. No one wanted to risk their head for the sake of innovation.

And then, gritting their teeth, states realized: if risks are not limited, there simply will be no economy. They decided to make it so that if your business fails, you only lose what you invested in the charter capital. Your house, wife, children, and dog remain yours. This was not an act of kindness, but a cold calculation: people breathed a sigh of relief, pulled out their savings, and the Industrial Revolution began.

And now, look at what is happening today. The state, intoxicated by a thirst for control and tax collection, is methodically destroying the very essence of “limited liability.” The curse of modern business is so-called subsidiary liability. The tax authorities or creditors can easily come after an entrepreneur’s personal property. Underpaid taxes because a counterparty turned out to be a fraud? Hand over your car, your apartment, and we’ll even freeze your grandmother’s accounts.

What does this lead to? Certainly not to prosperity. Sensible people do not want to try doing anything under such conditions. Business goes deep into the shadows, operating in cash, through crypto, registering companies to “drop” homeless people, or simply closing down. People refuse to create because the price of error has once again become fatal.

But let’s go further. Currently, we live in two worlds – the physical and the digital. And while in business they try to deprive us of protection, in the Internet, there was none to begin with. Today, the Web is a minefield with unlimited liability. You wrote the wrong comment, reposted a meme, or argued with the wrong person on a forum – and suddenly, someone is knocking on your real-life door. Imagine you are playing a video game where your character’s death means you lose a finger in real life. How many people would want to play? Exactly.

To liberate the network, it is vital that we transfer the concept of limited liability online. Following the principle: “What happens in Vegas, stays in Vegas.” What is said and done online (within the scope of network activity, exchange of opinions, and virtual interactions) must stay online!

Conservatives, of course, will howl that this will lead to anarchy online and everyone will hide behind masks. But in reality, the exact opposite will happen. People obsessively hide their identities, use double VPNs, and invent nicknames precisely because they fear real-world physical consequences.

If a person knows for a fact that the maximum they risk for their words online is a platform ban, a loss of virtual rating, or a digital block within a specific community, they will relax. They will no longer need to hide. Users will begin to voluntarily and actively reveal their identities because building a real reputation is profitable. A true economy of trust will emerge.

Voluntarist, Bitarch

Stop making excuses, or why messiness is cool!

Libertarians are often accused that without a strong state, we will have mess and chaos. And for some reason, we usually start making excuses, saying that there will be no mess, that we will have order too! By doing this, we haven’t even really said anything yet, but we have already taken a seat in the defendant’s dock. This is a losing strategy by design, because when you are making excuses, you look like a loser. Someone else’s accusation sets the rules of the conversation, and you are trying to earn leniency. Therefore, it is worth going on the attack and saying: mess and chaos are cool!

Different schools, unexpected ideas, dissimilar people, debates, experiments, new ways of living – this is why we need freedom, and we should only be proud of such “mess.” Development has a feature that is inconvenient for those in charge: it needs options. An evolutionary mechanism also works in society: new ideas and practices emerge, people test them, adopt them, combine them, and remake them. Diversity provides material for searching, and feedback helps to learn. But when only a single method is allowed, society is deprived of the opportunity to compare. And for cultural evolution, unlike biological evolution, it is enough just to exchange a successful idea – there is no need to wait for the birth of the next generation.

Take education, for example. One child loves a strict schedule, another gets excited about physics while assembling a bicycle, a third needs a small group and a calm pace. Let there be different schools, homeschooling, workshops, and online classes. Let teachers try new methods, show results, and adopt each other’s findings. Parents and children get a choice. The convenience of reporting is a poor reason to cut everyone to the same cloth.

Scientific and technological progress looks roughly the same. Programmers publish code, colleagues find bugs, and someone builds a new tool based on that. Different laboratories test different hypotheses. Competitors become partners, and an amateur suggests an unexpected solution to a specialist. It is useful when a person with an idea has several doors they can knock on. After all, you cannot pre-approve a plan of inspirations.

In medicine and biotech, such an opportunity is particularly precious. Katalin Karikó faced years of funding rejections for her RNA research, but later, her collaboration with Drew Weissman helped create RNA vaccines and earned them a Nobel Prize. The conclusion here is simple: different research groups, approaches, and sources of money are needed. A researcher must have the opportunity to challenge the conventional approach and find support for a different hypothesis. A single commission can easily be wrong, so it would be terrible to hand it the keys to all the laboratories.

Diversity is even more important in cities. Housing, small shops, workshops, cafes, a courtyard with trees – every part of a neighborhood has its own life. Imagine if residents could agree on a courtyard garden, an entrepreneur could revive a vacant space, or neighbors could test a new use for a common area. They try it, see who finds it convenient and who finds it bothersome, and then they fix it. The neighborhood gets the chance to change gradually, taking into account the experience of those who live there.

It is even more interesting with social norms. Some live in large families, some live alone, some share a household with friends. One person changes professions at fifty, another chooses the role of a father who looks after the children while the mother builds her career. Thanks to such people, others’ conceptions of what a possible life looks like are expanded. Even if we personally feel fine with the old way, someone else’s freedom of choice makes the world more spacious.

Of course, this diversity comes with working conditions: voluntariness, respect for the rights of others, responsibility for harm caused, and the ability to criticize and refuse. Thanks to them, one can try things, notice mistakes, and correct them. It is good to live in a society where you can say: “Let’s try something different.” In a place where a new idea gets a chance, and a dissenter can find like-minded people and do things their own way. If all of this is called “mess and chaos” – we should accept it with pride!

Voluntarist, Bitarch

“There is no point in lowering taxes: greedy corporations will immediately raise prices and suck every last penny out of you”

You have surely heard similar “masterpieces” of statist thought. As soon as you mention that the state skins an ordinary worker alive through taxes, excises, and levies, a defender of the “strong hand” immediately appears. They confidently declare that if, for example, VAT were abolished or levies reduced, ordinary people would not become wealthier, because capitalists are just waiting for this to instantly rewrite the price tags on bread, gasoline, and sneakers by exactly the amount of the savings obtained. But let us take this fairy tale apart piece by piece, because there is certainly very little common sense in it.

Let us start with the fact that a commercial firm does not wait for a tax cut to suddenly begin maximizing profit. It tries to squeeze out the maximum right now, every second. Why does a cup of coffee at the local coffee shop cost 200 rubles instead of 800? It is not due to the barista’s boundless love for the proletariat. The price is held back by three market forces.

First of all, there is a competitor across the street who would gladly brew you coffee for 190 to take your money instead of them. There are also substitute goods (buying a jar of instant coffee, brewing tea in a thermos, or grabbing an energy drink). Finally, you have the right to tell the coffee shop to go to hell and not buy anything at all.

As we can see, if a seller can raise the price tomorrow without losing customers, they will do it today. If they haven’t done it today, it means the market does not allow it.

Regulation enthusiasts also sincerely believe in the myth that the price of a good is equal to the sum of all the money remaining in the buyer’s pocket. If this were true, in low-tax countries, absolutely everything would cost many times more by the magnitude of the tax savings. But reality works exactly the opposite way. In low-tax Dubai, electronics and cars often cost much less than in highly regulated Europe, where a massive VAT, draconian duties, and packaging environmental disposal fees are tacked onto the price.

Taxes are costs. For you and for business. When taxes decrease, the production and delivery of goods become cheaper. And in a free market, an enterprising rogue is instantly found who drops the price by 5–10% to lure away every single customer in the area. It is precisely the thirst for profit that forces capitalists to compete for your ruble and drive prices down, rather than orchestrating Masonic cartel conspiracies.

There is also one interesting paradox. The very same person who demands that taxes not be touched, otherwise businesses will immediately hike prices and take everything, literally in the next message claims that to improve people’s well-being, one should simply raise the tax-free minimum, introduce benefits, and distribute targeted subsidies to people.

That is, if officials stop taking 300 dollars from you in taxes, greedy corporations will instantly take them through price increases. But if those same officials leave you with that 300 dollars in the form of a “state benefit” or an “allowance,” will corporations suddenly go blind, feel shy, and pass you by? What magic sensor in the pocket of an ordinary worker distinguishes a “dollar from a tax cut” from a “dollar from a social handout”? Why is it that in one case businesses immediately devour everything, but in another, they submissively leave the money to the person? There is no sense in this.

In short, this whole tale relies on deep-seated paternalism, suggesting that someone must rob a person who has no other options. Either the home state (allegedly for the common good), or an evil merchant. However, the difference is fundamental. The state takes your money under the threat of prison and a baton—you have no “unsubscribe” button. But you give money to corporations voluntarily. You vote with your ruble. If a supermarket triples the price of buckwheat, it will be left with a rotting warehouse and a hole in its balance sheet, because people will go to the neighboring stall.

The more money ordinary people have, the more power is in their hands. The power to accumulate capital, to invest, to support honest producers, and to punish arrogant monopolists with their rubles!

Voluntarist, Bitarch

The Lindsay Clancy Case: How Justifying Murder Returns Women to the Middle Ages

Imagine the quiet town of Daxbury in Massachusetts. Expensive houses, manicured lawns, the perfect picture of the American Dream. In one of these houses lived Lindsey Clancy—a maternity ward nurse from a Boston clinic, an exemplary mother of three.

But in January 2023, everything went wrong. Lindsey sent her husband to pick up a pre-ordered dinner from a restaurant and run into a pharmacy for children’s syrup—a routine twenty-minute errand. As soon as the door closed behind the man, the caring mother sent five-year-old Cora, three-year-old Dawson, and eight-month-old Callan down to the basement, after which she methodically strangled each of them with sports bands. Then, she made shallow cuts to her wrists and neck and dramatically jumped from a second-story window. The children died in terrible agony, but Lindsey herself survived, left with a spinal fracture and a disability.

It would seem we are facing a monstrous tragedy, an example of destructive madness, and a legal precedent. But then, a chorus of radical feminists rolled out. A literal coven began: hundreds of activists in pink T-shirts outside the courthouse, sobbing on social media, a campaign under the slogan “Believe Her,” and intoxicating millions in donations.

And the icing on this cake of madness was their general legal line. The ladies stated quite seriously that Lindsey was absolutely innocent, that she could not be judged, and that forced treatment is literally fascism, sexism, and patriarchal violence. Why? Because “it’s all hormones, postpartum psychosis, biology clouded her judgment; a woman in such a state is not in control of herself, and therefore bears no responsibility.”

However, let’s imagine what it would mean if we accepted such logic. It would mean that the state is obliged to immediately recognize women as legally incompetent beings. If hormones make them insane berserkers without control over their own bodies, then what use is a ballot for them? What right do they have to drive a one-and-a-half-ton vehicle on a busy highway? What right do they have to sign credit agreements, own real estate, or hold responsible positions? Lindsey, for the record, worked as a nurse herself and administered IV drips to other people’s children!

With such an argument, radical feminists are literally demanding a return to the Early Middle Ages, when a woman was considered a legal appendage, a domestic pet, for whose destructive escapades the legal master—the father or husband—was held responsible. Are modern emancipated activists really dreaming of the status of pedigreed livestock just to bail out an infanticide?

Now for the most bitter part of this entire story: this nightmare should never have happened in the first place! You probably thought we were about to start talking again about the need to strengthen violence inhibition mechanisms, but that only solves half the problem. By limiting the level of aggression, you save the child’s life, but you do not save them from emotional hell.

In the case of severe postpartum depression, a mother remains a scorched desert. She is physically incapable of loving the infant, the child grows up with a crippled psyche due to emotional deprivation, and the woman herself quietly goes mad from guilt. And this is where a real long-term solution must enter the stage—medications to enhance attachment (bonding). The neurobiology of attachment formation based on oxytocin and dopamine loops has been known to science for thirty years, if not more. There is absolutely no magic in creating targeted drugs to induce attachment.

But, as you have probably already guessed, the stationary bandit reliably keeps the barrier closed. Regulators like the FDA are cowards and bureaucrats who are panickily afraid of any innovation, forcing people to swallow half-century-old formulas for decades. They demand billions of dollars and decades of bureaucratic humiliation just for a few formal approvals.

Thus, due to state regulators, the problem remains unsolved, and the story of Lindsey Clancy threatens to repeat itself one day.

Voluntarist, Bitarch

From legalization to the Gulag – one step away? Analyzing the main mistake of conservatives and life hacks for persuading them

You are likely familiar with the situation where you try to explain to a friend with conservative views why decriminalization is normal, or why the state should not meddle in your bedroom, and in response, you get something like this:

– Today you allow same-sex marriage, and tomorrow they’ll start marrying dogs!
– Today you don’t imprison a drug addict, and tomorrow we’ll have a zombie apocalypse on our streets!

Of course, such argumentation will seem absurd to you, and it will be difficult to find meaning in it. But science has finally explained what is happening in the heads of our authoritarian opponents. And, most importantly, it has given us the keys to how to work with this. Recently, a fresh study was published in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, which puts everything in its place. So, let’s analyze how we can use this for the benefit of freedom.

The study confirmed what we already suspected: conservatives are much more prone to believing in arguments like the “Slippery Slope.” This is when a small, seemingly harmless action (eating a cookie) inevitably leads to a catastrophe (gaining 300 kg and dying). For a conservative, the world is a very fragile system. Pull out one brick (a tradition, a law), and the entire building of civilization will collapse. But here’s the thing: the study showed that this tendency is based on intuitive thinking. It is a “gut feeling,” an evolutionary mechanism, similar to how hearing a rustle in the bushes might make us immediately think it’s a tiger and that it’s better to run.

The most interesting part of the study is the experiment that showed how to switch this effect off. Scientists made conservatives wait 10 seconds before responding and asked them to “think carefully.” After this, the gap between liberals and conservatives narrowed to a minimum. As soon as “slow thinking” (analytics) is activated, the fear of the slippery slope evaporates.

How, then, can one effectively persuade conservatives? Based on this data, we obtain the following strategy for debating conservatives (and statists of all kinds):

First, it is important to slow down the pace and remove emotion. You need to switch your opponent’s brain from the “fast response system” (intuition) to the “deep analysis system.” Do not press; instead, ask questions that require a pause and reflection. You are unlikely to convince someone by saying that legalization reduces crime, here is Portugal’s statistics. It is better to ask: “Do you think if a person drinks a beer on Friday, they will inevitably become an alcoholic in a year? No? Then why should it be different with weed? Let’s break down the chain!”

Second, you need to fill in the gaps in the chain. Research has shown that conservatives believe in the “slippery slope” only if the intermediate steps are unclear to them. You must always argue step-by-step: A leads to B, B leads to C. If you skip steps, your opponent’s intuition will fill in the gaps with monsters.

Third, use their own weapons. Libertarians also frequently resort to the “slippery slope.” For example, “taxes are robbery, and even the slightest regulation is a direct path to slavery.” Use this!

Are conservatives afraid of chaos? Show them that expanding state powers is the most dangerous slippery slope of all. “If we allow an official to decide what we read/watch/smoke today, then tomorrow they will decide where we work and how we pray. Do you really want to give a Major Comrade that kind of power?”.

Are conservatives afraid of terrorism? Show them that the development of scientific and technological progress in a society where psychopaths with a weak version of the violence inhibitor are present will inevitably lead to global catastrophe and the self-destruction of all humanity, whereas attempting to mitigate these risks through increased surveillance and state regulation will make normal life impossible, turning it into an endless airport security check, but without any guarantee that some psychopath won’t still manage to “slip under the radar.” Consequently, a technologically advanced society has no way to avoid the practice of strengthening the violence inhibitor in psychopaths!

Voluntarist, Bitarch

A license for one’s own mouth: illusions about freedom of speech in the USA are time to bury

It is hard not to notice that our domestic liberals possess an incurable form of cargo cult. They still fervently believe that across the ocean, a shining city on a hill has been built, where the First Amendment to the US Constitution protects any citizen better than tank armor. They claim that in the “civilized world,” even the most vengeful president or an out-of-control official would not dare to gag a TV presenter, and that freedom of broadcasting to a million-strong audience is an unshakeable sacred cow. But it seems it is time for them to take off their rose-colored glasses.

Recently, a demonstrative drama unfolded in the USA, which even the witnesses of “free America” certainly cannot ignore. Jimmy Kimmel’s immensely popular late-night show on the national ABC television channel simply cut out a full interview with Democratic Senate candidate James Talarico from the broadcast. They weren’t afraid of viewer boycotts or advertiser whims. The leadership of the media giant panicked and tossed the conversation from the broadcast schedule to the backwaters of YouTube simply because officials from the Trump administration unequivocally cocked the hammer of the regulatory club known as the FCC (Federal Communications Commission).

But what about the First Amendment, under which the state has no right to silence anyone? Watch closely, for we are witnessing a classic trick of state-level swindling. Why should the Leviathan crudely ban words if it can instead subjugate the infrastructure? Officials do not enter the studio shouting about the introduction of censorship. No, they simply politely state that the airwaves are a scarce public resource, that there is a sacred “Equal Time Rule” and a doctrine of serving the public interest. And also that the local ABC network television stations happen to have broadcasting licenses up for renewal, and it would be extremely unfortunate if the commission perceived a political bias in their evening jokes and delayed the review by a couple of years or so.

Trump’s new appointee as head of the FCC, Brendan Carr, demonstratively threw away years of leniency for entertainment news and openly threatened the Disney holding company with the cancellation of its licenses. And what did the multi-billion dollar corporation do? It instantly tucked its tail between its legs and engaged in primitive self-censorship.

Now is the perfect time to open a libertarian classic. As early as 1959, future Nobel laureate Ronald Coase released a devastating scientific paper on the creation of the FCC. Coase literally demonstrated with simple examples: the radio frequency spectrum is fundamentally no different from plots of land. It is an ordinary limited resource that should belong to broadcasters as full private property based on the principle of first use (homesteading). All overlaps, noise, and frequency disputes are elementary solved through the institution of private property and courts—without a single ministerial parasite.

But a century ago, the American state intentionally nationalized radio waves, declaring them “public domain.” Why? The answer is obvious: solely for the sake of political control. So that over everyone who picks up a microphone hangs the sword of Damocles of bureaucratic favor, and at the same time, no one could complain that some amendment was being violated.

It is time for libertarians to take note: a state license is an absolute oxymoron for freedom. What is licensing by its very nature? The state first forcibly steals your natural right to speak, broadcast, trade, or produce, and then, for money and an oath of submission, sells you a scrap of stamped paper: “Fine, we allow it for now, but if you behave badly, we’ll take it away.” A right, reduced to the status of a licensable handout from an official, instantly ceases to be a right.

Therefore, it is time to finally purge the provincial cargo cult from within and stop praying to the stars and stripes. American statism is exactly the same predatory stationary bandit, it has simply learned to hide its claws behind complex bureaucratic procedures.

Voluntarist, Bitarch

How the state filtered migrants so that only psychopaths were left on the streets

Ceuta is a tiny Spanish enclave on the Moroccan coast. And recently, a real drama has unfolded there. An interview with a local resident, who went out to protest against the dominance of illegals, went viral online. She described an interesting dynamic: once the guys who sailed in from Morocco realized that the Spanish state had no intention of handing out legalization and documents on a silver platter, the vast majority left the city. It would seem that bureaucracy won? Far from it.

The most sane people left. Those who wanted to work honestly, did not want problems with the law, and were looking for a normal life. But who stayed? Aggressive psychopaths, thugs, and degenerates, of course. They don’t care about legal status, the police, or the laws. In the end, normal people left, and concentrated crime settled on the streets. Now, Spanish women are simply afraid to leave their homes after sunset.

It turned out to be a classic, crystal-clear example of the law of negative selection. But let’s step back a little to understand how Spain even reached this state of affairs.

The Spanish authorities have been complaining for years about the demographic pit, about the fact that there is no one to earn pensions. And that means mass legalization of hundreds of thousands of migrants is urgently needed! But why did this hole form in a warm, fertile country? Because the state has suffocated its own population with care and regulation. Incredible tax pressure, a bloated state apparatus, draconian labor laws (where hiring a young man is a lifelong risk, because firing him later will cost you more), insane housing prices due to urban planning restrictions. And on top of that—thousands of absurd laws about victimless “crimes,” turning the average citizen into a perpetual neurotic and potential lawbreaker. A person lives in permanent stress under the microscope of a bureaucrat. And as any biologist knows, animals in captivity simply do not reproduce.

And now let’s see what happens when the state begins to clumsily “fight” immigration using its usual prohibitive methods.

If a person is a normal, sane hard worker, then he respects private property and personal boundaries. Yes, he might have crossed the strait illegally in search of a better life. But if he is told that he won’t be allowed to work legally here, that he will have no rights, and that deportation awaits him at the slightest stir, what will he do? He will go somewhere where there are chances, or return home. He has something to lose: his own safety, his reputation, the prospect of a stable income.

And who has nothing to lose? A completely broken sociopath. He deeply doesn’t care about residence permits, employment contracts, or the police. The police didn’t scare him in his homeland, and they won’t scare him here (especially knowing the toothlessness of European justice). He had no intention of integrating into the economy. His craft is robbery and violence.

By banning or making legal stay as difficult as possible, the state builds a barrier that filters out the cautious, the moderate, and the constructive. But only predators step over it. This works exactly the same as with gun bans: when authorities ban pistols, they disappear from law-abiding citizens but do not go anywhere for bandits. When the state bans drugs, it does not destroy demand – it simply hands the market over to bloody cartels instead of civilized pharmacies. And when the state bluntly “bans migration” instead of making way for free trade, private hiring, and strict protection of private property from encroachments – it is guaranteed to result in streets overwhelmed by a wave of violence.

In the end, we get a weeping simple woman from Ceuta, who cannot walk to the store in the evening. First, the stationary bandit stripped her of taxes and deprived her fellow citizens of a future, and then created a perfect sanctuary for those who recognize no rules at all. However, there is nothing new: any state intervention always only makes things worse. Even where it hypocritically promises to “restore order”!

Voluntarist, Bitarch

The Illusion of a Satiated Demographic Sunset: Why There Will Be No One to Fix Robots in a Half-Empty World

We always say that if you regulate every step, burden a person with a million prohibitions, licenses, and fines for every sneeze, people will simply stop having children. A human is a biological being, and animals in cramped cages do not reproduce. But the response we get is simply, “So be it; there are too many people as it is, and if there are fewer, there will be no traffic jams, nature will cleanse itself, and silence and beauty will prevail.” Usually, we counter with economics: infrastructure will collapse, the solidarity pension system will burst, and markets will shrink to the size of a street stall. That is exactly what will happen. But behind this facade hides something far more terrifying—technological regression and the risk of a slow but certain extinction of humanity as a species.
 
Population reduction enthusiasts stubbornly see a human only as an “extra mouth,” a “source of carbon footprint,” and a walking problem. But a human is not just a mouth, but also a brain. It is the entrepreneurial spirit, ingenuity, and labor. So let’s break down in simple terms why the dream of a “small, cozy humanity” is a most dangerous illusion.
 
First, rare talents. Geniuses capable of driving fundamental science do not appear by government decree. They are born statistically rarely—roughly one in a million. If you have a population of 8 billion, you have a pool of eight thousand potential Einsteins, von Neumanns, and Turings. Cut the population in half, and you cut that pool by exactly 50%. Cut it even more, and breakthrough ideas will become many times fewer. And yet, it is these individuals who create the technologies that later feed and heal everyone.
 
Second, the specialization trap. Modern scientific and technological progress relies on an incredibly deep division of labor. In the 18th century, an erudite person could understand mechanics, botany, and philosophy. But today, the low-hanging fruit of science has already been picked. To move the edge of knowledge even a millimeter, thousands of ultra-specialists are needed. One person cannot design a lithographic scanner for chips, synthesize a molecule for a rare cancer, and build a thermonuclear reactor all at once. The larger the society, the more unique, niche professions it can afford. A small society, even if everyone has three higher education degrees, is physically incapable of maintaining millions of complex competencies simultaneously.
 
Thirdly, economies of scale and technological accessibility. Developing a new processor or medication costs billions of dollars. In a global market of billions of people, these colossal costs are spread thin—resulting in penny-priced pills and affordable smartphones. Shrink the market, and the most complex projects will cease to be profitable. Businesses simply will not invest in something they have no one to sell to. First, niche drugs for rare diseases will disappear, then specialized equipment, and eventually entire industries. The state, of course, will attempt to save the situation with “subsidies,” but taking money from a shrinking economy is a path toward an even faster collapse.
 
Fourthly, knowledge does not live in books. Blueprints without a living chain of succession are just dead terabytes of data. Complex technology lives only in the hands of practitioners: when a gray-haired engineer passes on implicit skills to a young graduate student right at the machine tool or in the laboratory. If one generation is replaced by a much smaller one, the chains break. Humanity has lost technologies more than once—from the recipe for Roman concrete to the ability to quickly reproduce the rocket engines of the moon program.
 
And finally, we cannot simply stand still. Nature does not take pauses for a “cozy life.” Bacteria mutate and develop resistance to antibiotics. The climate presents surprises, infrastructure decays, and space threats have not gone anywhere. For civilization to simply maintain its current level of security, it must run as fast as it can forward—discovering new energy sources, creating new materials, and new medicines. If we slow down the scientific and technological progress due to a shortage of brains, we are not staying in place, but beginning to slowly slide into a new dark age.

Voluntarist, Bitarch

Psychopathy – a zombie idea? Not quite!

Recently, the article by Rasmus Rosenberg Larsen has made waves, attempting to completely refute the concept of psychopathy and labeling it a “zombie idea.” The author concludes that psychopathy does not exist in principle, and that the scientific community’s interest in this idea is fueled only by the cultural popularity of the concept. But do such claims actually hold water, or is this just another attempt to ride the hype by denying the obvious? Let us examine everything in order.

First of all, the author refers to his own meta-analysis, in which he finds that, according to research data, psychopathic personalities perform no worse than ordinary people on empathy tests. However, it is extremely important to note that modern science does not claim an absolute inability of psychopaths to empathize. Often, the discussion concerns a deficit in affective empathy (the ability to feel the emotions of others while observing them) to varying degrees, while simultaneously, cognitive empathy (the mere ability to read others’ emotions without feeling them) is frequently fully intact. The author of the article primarily uses empathy as a monolithic construct, which is fundamentally incorrect.

Furthermore, such results may have a rather interesting explanation—psychopathy may consist not in the absence of empathy itself, but merely in the absence of its automatic activation. For instance, in one experiment, psychopaths were found to have the same level of mirror neuron activation (which is typically associated with empathy) as ordinary people. But this only occurred when they were given the task of manifesting it intentionally! As for spontaneous empathy, they demonstrated a clear deficit in neural activity in that case. Another experiment similarly proved the ability of psychopaths to take the perspective of others (to understand their state and thoughts), but only when it is an intentional task. At the same time, automatic (reflexive) perspective-taking occurs only in low-psychopathic personalities.

The author also uses psychopathy itself as a monolithic construct, without paying particular attention to its individual traits and the connections between them. This is also an extremely incorrect approach, as in modern research, results and conclusions are often presented within the framework of multi-factor models of psychopathy, which are perfectly functional.

There are also moments where the author has explicitly lied. He claims that frequently cited studies in favor of the psychopathy concept—for example, neurobiologist James Blair’s article on the mechanism of violence inhibition, which normally deters a person from harming others, the presence of moral-psychological impairments in psychopaths, as well as certain neurophysiological studies—are merely isolated pieces of evidence and therefore cannot be taken seriously. However, Blair’s core positions and his violence inhibitor model, such as the reduced ability of violent and psychopathic personalities to perceive distress signals (sadness, fear, etc.) from others, have been replicated by dozens of studies! Furthermore, there is already a great deal of evidence regarding the link between structural brain impairments and psychopathy.

Finally, the author decided not to mention the strongest argument in favor of the psychopathy concept at all: its extremely high predictive power regarding violent crime, and especially murder. This, for example, is supported by numerous studies and meta-analyses by criminologist Matt DeLisi. Moreover, so far there is not a single study that refutes such a link. As forensic psychologist John Marshall notes in one of his articles, psychopathy is the strongest indicator of violence, it is difficult to ignore in the matter of predicting such behavior, and the fact that the “average” criminal who commits a murder demonstrates moderate manifestations of psychopathy underscores that this is not just a rare subtype of murderers, but a general trend for all cases of lethal violence.

Voluntarist, Bitarch