Nostr, interim results

About a year and a half ago, the Nostr protocol was first mentioned in my channel — initially as the basis for a recurrent Lightning payments engine, and subsequently more detailed impressions were given regarding the protocol as a means of decentralized publishing. What has changed since then?

Unfortunately, not much. The adoption of Nostr is happening quite slowly, and even in Montelibero, no one really uses it properly (although Sondre from Liberstad is even writing his own software for Nostr, we don’t use it). I have tried several clients and settled on Amethyst for Android and Gossip for Windows. Web services are all terrible; none have gained traction. The vast majority of Nostr clients cosplay Twitter, except without character limits — which results in a complete lack of the ability to make posts with human-readable formatting. In principle, this is logical: even if one client understands a post with markup, another won’t bother with it. Decentralization encourages a certain degree of primitivism.

The browser application Alby has long relied on using a custodial Lightning wallet, but its support is ending soon, and now those interested are being offered to either set up their own node from the same provider or rent a ready-made one. Overall, this is sensible, but since I have no idea how to set up a node on a server, I had to just install it on my laptop, and now, as I understand it, post donations can only be sent when the node is online. Perhaps I’ll manage to do it properly eventually, but honestly, this task is not a high priority; usually, it’s just trivial stuff coming in anyway. For my part, I use these satoshis to reward other people’s posts—a simple cycle of gratitude in the blogosphere.

As for Nostr to start being widely adopted in Montelibero, it seems we need some serious persecution of freedom of speech; without that, no one will leave Telegram voluntarily. I understand perfectly)))

And what about under ancap..?

I constantly receive the same type of questions: how will this or that thing be implemented under ancap, given that it is currently implemented either directly by the state or by private entities, but under conditions of heavy state regulation. Quite often, these kinds of questions have a boundary condition: not everyone has the money to buy this thing on a free market, which is precisely what causes the questioner’s interest: how to provide the needy with this expensive thing if not through robbery.

Of course, one could go on for a long time saying that in a free, unregulated, competitive market, this desperately needed thing will be cheaper and of higher quality than it is today, but such arguments cannot fully negate the aforementioned boundary condition: not everyone will have the money for it regardless, and there will still remain the possibility that some of those who desperately need it will not have the money. Who will help them buy it?

I have a simple answer: you will do it yourselves, those who are so concerned about this issue. Because it is personally important to you that the needy receive this thing (otherwise, you wouldn’t be so concerned about this question). And it will not be particularly taxing for you personally, because you will be wealthy enough to afford this small expense. Why? Because you can buy Bitcoin right now. Even if it’s not a whole Bitcoin, but some fraction. And by the time ancap arrives on Earth, today’s acquisition will be so valuable that you will easily be able to afford such small-scale charity.

Get to it)))

A question about Montelibero’s tokenomics

Why did Monteliberro create an internal financial system similar to fiat (with artificial tokens and a trusted third party), and why do you support this decision by involving people? If the Montenegrin authorities deem Monteliberro’s internal payment tokens as securities and shut the operation down, will you take on the responsibility of reimbursing people for their financial losses? After all, it is obvious that abandoning Bitcoin in favor of one’s own internal shitcoin is merely a way for the owner and members of his politburo to make money.

Vito

To understand the logic behind the emergence of EURMTL, let’s compare Montenegro, for example, with El Salvador.

Neither state has its own sovereignly issued national currency. In El Salvador, the legal means of payment are the US dollar and Bitcoin. In Montenegro, it is the euro. Formally, the circulation of other fiat, as well as cryptocurrencies, is not regulated in any way, but in practice, we see a complete absence of street exchange points (unlike neighboring Serbia, where exchange offices are on every corner) and a complete absence of crypto ATMs (there was only one in the entire country, and even that one was arrested by the state, because in the absence of regulations, one agency believed “what is not permitted is forbidden,” another “what is not forbidden is permitted,” and in reality, the crypto ATM owners simply lacked sufficiently strong protection).

In El Salvador, a business owner, for the most part, does not care whether a client pays in dollars or Bitcoin. The exchange spread in the BTC/USDT pair is negligible, and the exchange between USDT and dollar cash is also likely carried out with minimal commissions. Thus, an entrepreneur can easily transfer money from one form to another literally on the fly, based on their preference for which form is more convenient for storing value.

And what about Montenegro? An entrepreneur has the right to accept only euros, in cash or non-cash form. If, instead of euros, he accepts anything else, for example, Bitcoin, he must put the euro equivalent of the received values from his own stash into the cash register, otherwise, the state will issue him a massive fine. This means he needs tools for convenient conversion. The exchange spread in the BTC/EUR pair is slightly higher than in the pair with the dollar, but tolerable. However, there is no sufficiently liquid euro-pegged stablecoin in existence; everyone uses dollar stables. And in order to withdraw money from an exchange to a bank card, one needs to have a bank card and a bank that will not block such an operation. Thus, for our potential Bitcoin maximalist, it would be more reliable to find some kind of money changer who will buy his bitcoins for euro cash, and then the entrepreneur can use the acquired euro cash to put into his own cash register and tell the state: here, look, I sold my stuff for euros and am ready to report to you. The commission for such street exchange is about 5%, and the daily exchange rate of Bitcoin relative to the euro also fluctuates freely by about the same amount, so on an unlucky day, you can lose a lot of money.

Of course, when calculating things yesterday, there were no problems with telling each other prices in Bitcoin and settling with it. In fact, for large deals, we regularly do exactly that, because there aren’t many maniacs willing to hold large sums in fiat; Bitcoin is the savings tool. But imagine a gathering in a restaurant. Seven people walked around for three hours, racked up a bill of two hundred euros, and the owner wouldn’t even think about splitting the check because, by local customs, one person always pays. You could, of course, open calculators and start calculating: here this unfortunate owner of a two-hundred-euro note pays for everyone, the Bitcoin to Euro exchange rate is such-and-such, so now let him issue an invoice in Lightning to each drinking companion for the Bitcoin equivalent of the debt expressed in euros. Very damn convenient, especially when everyone is tipsy.

Therefore, we simply invented our own Euro stablecoin and started using it, primarily for these kinds of small mutual settlements. And so that the counterparty would willingly accept these tokens, some project participants took on a free social burden—the obligation to exchange EURMTL for EuroCash for anyone who wishes, without a commission. It is a heavy burden. I, for example, do not dare take on such obligations for any significant amount, because it would require freezing my own capital in EuroCash and EURMTL, and the mere prospect of having so much money sitting not in Bitcoin simply makes me sick.

I hope I have managed to make it clear that maintaining the EURMTL infrastructure is not a profit for the issuer, but an expense. For what purpose does it incur them? The issuer of mules is the Montelibero investment fund. Naturally, it would not build such an impressive and costly infrastructure for the free exchange of mules for cash and back just to provide the Montelibero community members with a tool for splitting a cafe bill. The main purpose of the infrastructure is to make it convenient for people to buy fund shares and receive dividends on them. Why not conduct all settlements in Bitcoin? Because the fund, by attracting investments, invests them into local businesses. A local business, having received investments in any currency, will be forced to convert them into euros to spend on its subsequent operating activities. It will also receive its profits in euros. Under these conditions, fixing a business’s debt obligations in Bitcoin means predetermining its future bankruptcy, as the long-term growth rate of Bitcoin’s exchange rate exceeds the income of almost any business.

Of course, the upcoming hyperbitcoinization will mean a transition to ubiquitous settlements in Bitcoin, but it will also mean a significant decrease in the growth rate of Bitcoin’s purchasing power; for now, during this transition period, it is necessary to conduct settlements and hold some reserves in currencies whose long-term value is decreasing.

Now let’s talk about the risks of direct intervention by the Montenegrin state in the Montelibero tokenomics by declaring any tokenized liabilities as securities, the circulation of which requires approval from the state financial regulator.

Yes, for some time the global trend was exactly this, and it was reflected in the fact that the US jurisdiction was becoming increasingly toxic for cryptocurrencies. What did this lead to? To the ruling party suffering a crushing defeat in all branches of government under the promises of its opponents to significantly deregulate the industry. I foresee a substantial reduction in the powers of the US Securities and Exchange Commission regarding cryptocurrencies, European regulators following suit in the same vein, and a complete loss of interest from the Montenegrin regulator in the relevant sphere, because it is no longer fashionable.

Let’s assume, however, that instead of following American trends, the EU and Montenegro fall, say, under China’s influence. They ban cryptocurrencies or subject them to a large number of regulations. It is clear that in this case, any crypto enthusiasts in Montenegro will feel just as nervous as, say, marijuana sellers. In other words, only a handful of people will be held accountable for this undoubtedly prohibited business, purely to demonstrate that the state is working hard in this direction. Naturally, in this case, Montelibero will have to move its entire infrastructure from the simple, convenient, cheap, but very transparent Stellar to some other blockchain. We have already had experience working with tokens on the Liquid sidechain. It was a terrible hassle, but better than nothing.

There will be no need for me to compensate Montelibero tokenomics participants for their financial losses; instead, I will have to participate in developing manuals for transitioning to systems with higher levels of privacy. I do not have the resources to do this in advance, but I consider such a scenario highly unlikely. Even if it were implemented, we would most likely just pause the tokenomics until a new solution is developed, and in the meantime, we will make do with Lightning payments.

To summarize.

  1. Montelibero tokenomics has evolved along an evolutionary path, following the real needs of the community more closely than the theoretical considerations of Bitcoin maximalists.
  2. Montelibero tokenomics will easily restructure either for settlements in Bitcoin under an optimistic hyperbitcoinization scenario, or for the use of secure mutual obligation accounting schemes under a pessimistic scenario of a sharp increase in state regulatory control.

Greetings to Franz Oppenheimer

Today in MTL-City, the development of the business accelerator under the Monteliberro investment fund was discussed. The head has changed there; the new one is currently taking over, trying to understand what he has gotten himself into, and estimating what to do about it.

Based on the results of the discussion, it seems to have become clear that the focus should not be on attracting new businesses, but on auditing those already invested in, either to ensure everything is fine there or to guess how to steer things out of trouble.

But that is just a side note. I simply want to share a thought that I voiced at this meeting.

When the Monteliberro project was just starting, a study was conducted on why Montenegro was the best place for its launch. It pointed to many favorable factors. The country is small, multinational, has sea access, and has democracy—it has everything so that Russians could come and carry out political transformations toward freedom and, to start with, achieve a powerful economic rise. In fact, it turned out that a small country means a tiny consumer market. That the absence of unconditional dominance by the Montenegrin national majority means the impossibility of obtaining citizenship. That sea access helps nothing in terms of the economy, because the country is effectively walled off by high tariffs on almost everything. And that no one will let Russians carry out any political transformations here; the citizens fight among themselves and change governments every two years, and to step into the line of fire under such conditions is an extremely foolish decision.

Therefore, essentially, the only reason for Rus to go to Montenegro now is that Montelibero is here. Yes, the location might not have been the most ideal choice, but we have already invested here, have already achieved significant success, and now other places are definitely worse. It turned out just like with Israel: the location there isn’t great, and the neighbors are aggressive, but once the Jews had already arrived and built so much, it truly made sense for those for whom it was all being built to go specifically there.

As for the motto of the updated Montelibero business accelerator, it has become “economy without politics.” A sort of return to libertarian classics.

What do you think about DOGE? Isn’t it true that creating a ministry to reduce ministries is an extremely efficient idea?

Anonymous question

The irony is quite understandable; however, we have the example of Argentina before our eyes: Milei also created a structure in charge of deregulation, and the reduction of the state apparatus there is indeed in full swing. And he doesn’t even have a parliamentary majority yet, whereas in the USA, the problem of passing necessary laws is theoretically much easier to solve.

Of course, we don’t even have an approximate idea of what pitfalls the American deep state hides—that’s why it’s called “deep.” However, it seems to me a good sign that the new department has been allocated very little time for everything, only until 2026, which means they will act quickly. The state machinery of sabotage is quite cumbersome, and there is indeed some chance to overcome its resistance while riding the momentum. Especially if acting in many directions at once, cutting through everything that can be reduced right now from what was planned, and letting what cannot be reduced wait for another convenient opportunity.

Many also snicker at the Ramaswamy/Musk duumvirate, but here there seems to be a fairly logical division of labor, where the former provides analytics, media support, and, if necessary, money, while the latter knows which bureaucrats to talk to and about what to ensure that orders stall less. Will they undermine each other? I doubt it. Musk was born outside the USA and therefore cannot have presidential ambitions; he doesn’t need political points at all. Viveck Ramaswamy, on the other hand, if he decides to run for president in three-plus years, will desperately need a story of maximum constructive cooperation with Musk, so he will lick his boots if necessary.

That’s how I see it. Forgive me for my perhaps excessive naivety and optimism; after all, political analysis is not my field, I am more used to writing fan fiction regarding politics.

How is the culture of libertarian political thinking structured?

Rinat Enikeev

Politics is how collective actions are customarily carried out in a given community. Political thinking is a complex of ideas and evaluations concerning politics. Libertarian political thinking is political thinking determined by libertarian principles. The culture of libertarian political thinking is how it is reproduced and promoted.

Now the full definition: the culture of libertarian political thinking is how the complex of ideas and evaluations regarding how collective actions are customarily carried out in society, determined by libertarian principles, is reproduced and promoted. How is this culture structured?

In modern society, politics very rarely corresponds to libertarian principles, so a libertarian usually involuntarily shuns politics. In what cases will they not shun it?

First, the collective action must be voluntary for its participants. Rallies by quota, mandatory elections, and the like will be sabotaged by a libertarian whenever possible.

Second, the collective action must pursue an obvious benefit for its participants. A libertarian is unlikely to be inclined to pull chestnuts out of the fire for others.

Third, collective action may involve causing harm only if it is intended to restore justice. Lynching or street clashes with police committing illegal acts may well fit into libertarian political thinking. Pogroms—unlikely.

How are all these values reproduced and promoted? Like many other cultural ideas: through personal example, references to successful political actions, and campaigning.

The channel is changing its format

First, I want to inform you that the epub of the Network State has been re-uploaded — there was a dynamic gif that e-readers didn’t recognize, so it had to be replaced with a static png.

Leaving my job finally happened, and now I want to devote more time to my channel. However, it turned out that in its current form, it burdens me more than anything, which is why posts appear rarely and without much enthusiasm. Therefore, the main thing I want to achieve now is to start enjoying it again. In this regard, I plan to run it differently. Instead of rare articles that barely fit into the format of a standard Telegram post, there will be frequent notes, usually without images — just certain thoughts that I want to share with readers. In the coming days, I will try to return to daily posts, just to establish the habit, and we’ll see where it goes from there.

I don’t intend to descend entirely into a blog format; I have Instagram for that. It is also possible that not every post will now be duplicated across all social networks, we’ll see.

Let me know in the comments which topics of notes would be most interesting to you.

Network State. EPUB version

This summer, I finished translating Balaji Srinivasan’s book The Network State. Not everyone finds it convenient to read from a browser screen, and the automatically generated PDF suffered from some layout issues and occasional missing chunks of text. So, slowly and for fun after work, I laid out a version in EPUB format for e-readers (while also proofreading several more bugs in the translation). Given how many links are scattered throughout the text, the task turned out to be quite meditative and kept me busy for several months. And you’ve just had a few months to save up enough money to donate to me.

Also, I am finally leaving my full-time job, which has taken a considerable amount of my time and energy over the last three years. So, in a couple of weeks, I will have far more opportunities to maintain the channel. I think some reformatting awaits it.

Inspired by a flying skyscraper

I wasn’t able to watch the Starship flight live, as I was on a business trip involving socializing and alcohol tastings. However, at the very first opportunity, I inquired about how things went and was overjoyed by the success.

In this regard, I want to reflect on a trend that has become particularly pronounced lately and is becoming a complete commonplace: in almost any state, an entrepreneur can face numerous problems related to their political stance, and the more of an innovator that entrepreneur is, the more likely it is that their political position will run counter to the mainstream — it is difficult to imagine a completely systemic innovator. Jack Ma in China, Pavel Durov in France, and Elon Musk in the USA are not even close to an exhaustive list, but merely a cross-section showing that this trend is quite global, and these entrepreneurs, for the most part, have nowhere to run.

A quite obvious question arises. Within libertarian circles, the idea of a Libertarian International wanders—an awareness of common interests among holders of libertarian values and the joint defense of these very interests, despite the individualistic nature of the libertarian ideology itself. One wonders: among entrepreneurs, who encounter systemic state opposition to the values that fuel their businesses, is there no demand for an Entrepreneurial International? What could the joint defense of common interests by entrepreneurs consist of, and are they capable of realizing them, despite the individualistic nature of any entrepreneurial activity, and especially innovative activity?

In a speculative free-market society, a person is wealthier and more respected the more benefit they bring to others. In a real society, where politics is mixed with the free market, such a person receives, in addition to wealth and respect, envy, which quickly turns into hatred—and a very active kind of hatred at that.

Of course, the most obvious move for entrepreneurs is to relocate their business to the freest possible jurisdiction. That is, to seek shelter under a politician who shares their values—someone like a hypothetical Milei. However, how many political systems can boast long-term continuity of political course? The alternation of power is a well-known democratic fetish. Therefore, an entrepreneur cannot trust a politician who lures them into their jurisdiction with promises of economic freedom. They know that in a few years, the politician will exit the stage, a leftist will crawl into their place, and will begin to demolish everything built by their predecessor. And relocating a business is a loss of time and money.

In response to all this, a libertarian will dig through a manual and provide a quite decent, well-theorized recipe: extraterritorial contractual jurisdictions. But that is also a business. And this service can only develop if there is stable, solvent demand. That is, conditional Durovs and Musks must at least signal their readiness to enter into a contract with someone who can and will agree to provide protection for their businesses from the appetites of territorial states and their greedy, envious voters. And then, perhaps, a couple of outlaws will be found who will dare to launch this honorable, yet extremely dangerous and responsible business.

Of course, variations are possible. For example, such a forceful entrepreneur might first launch their own service and only then offer their services to those in need. Or entrepreneurs might organize extraterritorial protection on their own.

For now, however, there is a feeling that entrepreneurs continue to rely on traditional political protection, funding one politician or another despite the obvious unreliability of this method. I don’t have a recipe for how to change their mindset. I am simply admiring the filigree landing of the fifth Starship booster on the launch pad and continue to marvel at how much harder social innovation is to implement than engineering…

MTL-Fest 2024, October 4, Tikhiy Omut. Getting to know Montelibero.

From October 4 to 6, MTL-Fest will take place in Bar, Montenegro, and its surroundings. Libertarians from various corners of the world are expected, including representatives of related libertarian projects. However, the description of a given libertarian community is usually made with rather broad strokes. Something like “Monteliberro is a movement to build a free society in Europe, starting with Montenegro”. It’s not even a lie, but there are no guarantees that the picture in the reader’s head after such a description will be even remotely similar to what exists in reality.

On October 5, many interesting talks about different approaches to building libertarian communities are expected. On October 6—many no less interesting talks about the tools we use. But this is all a bird’s-eye view; it will allow you to grasp trends, but it won’t let you fully feel who the people gathered in this very Monteliberro are and how they live. And that is exactly where one should start.

Therefore, on October 4, the first day of the festival, we invite everyone interested to Tikhiy Omut (this is a small agorist club of Monteliberro). There, you will be met by real people who will tell you a little about themselves: how they joined the movement, what they found on the ground, how they settled in, what they do, and how they interact with the community. Talks about structures and institutions will await you in the following days, but for a start—the purely human dimension.

There will be no presentations or other attributes of public lectures. We will sit around the table in an informal setting, enjoy some refreshments, and gradually move from storytelling to discussion, and perhaps we will even arrive at some interesting ideas.

We are gathering at 19:00, and we will head out whenever we decide to. For those who find it difficult to return home at night, we will offer an apartment in the center of Bar to stay overnight.

Entry to Omut is free, donations are welcome. Address: ulica Muftije Murtezira Karađuzovića, broj 12, Bar.