The moral philosopher and children

An interesting dispute occurred here on Twitter between two libertarians whom I quite respect.

On one side, @dobroum presented a universal moral philosophy, one of whose conclusions is the assertion that any violence against children is inadmissible, as well as the rather banal “it is better to be rich and healthy than poor and sick,” meaning that a family should be complete, everyone in the family should love one another, the father should earn enough to support the whole family, and the mother should prioritize raising offspring above any other hobby. And divorces, kindergartens, and single mothers harm children.

He was opposed by @VoiceInTwit, who argued that there are no universal parenting methods, that violence from children is quite acceptable to suppress with forceful means, and that in the real world one has to deal with imperfect situations—and if a moral philosophy with its universal principles cannot handle such situations, then its value is small.

Even from my retelling, it is not difficult to understand whose side I am on in this dispute. However, I should note that although this looks like a confrontation between the theorist Dobroum and the practitioner Voice, in fact, the situation is the opposite: the practitioner Dobroum (has children, raises them non-violently) against the theorist Voice (has no children of his own). Due to my own lack of children, my judgments will suffer from the same deficiency.

Nevertheless, a specific case of non-violent child-rearing only proves the fallacy of the thesis “non-violent upbringing is impossible,” yet this thesis is not being put forward in the debate. Instead, the thesis “non-violent upbringing is not always appropriate” is being advanced, and here the practice must move into the realm of theory to defend the opposing claim that “violent upbringing is always inappropriate.”

Alas, the attempt to justify the non-application of violence to children through a universal NAP runs into two obstacles. First, as Voice notes, in a situation where the NAP is violated by a child, they are deprived of the protection of the non-aggression principle. Otherwise, the NAP proves to be non-universal (violence can be used to suppress violence, but if violence is used by a child, it cannot be). Second, the problem of fuzzy boundaries arises in full force: not being competent from birth, an infant remains a will-less object of manipulation by adults for quite a long time; otherwise, they would not survive. There is no clear line between manipulation without consent and violence. An infant can be undressed without consent, whereas for an adult, this is usually a criminal offense. Meanwhile, universal moral principles should work, shouldn’t they? Unfortunately, with children, the use of crutches is inevitable: no matter how you look at it, they acquire legal personhood only gradually.

At this stage of the dispute, the advocate of non-violent treatment of children must take off the hat of a moral philosopher and become a practitioner again, bringing utilitarian arguments that those who have experienced childhood trauma statistically turn out to be stupider and unhappier by adulthood, after which one can fully immerse oneself in a discussion about how applicable statistics are to individual cases. And here, all the cards fall to the hands of the one who is skeptical of playing with statistics, because it was with those very same statistical arguments that we were fed before the forced COVID vaccination, as well as the stripping of the right to bear arms.

Raising a child is the responsibility of those who are doing it. And everyone does it, from parents to cartoon creators to a random passerby expressing their moral judgment to a child. A parent cannot and should not shield a child from any adverse influence. Likewise, a parent cannot claim an exclusive right to do whatever they please with their child—a random passerby may not limit themselves to rendering a moral judgment, but may also use force if they deem it necessary.

So, about the use of force. I very much hope that even the most non-violent moral philosopher still teaches her girls to use it. This includes explaining in which situations it is appropriate to use force, even if it is not being directly used against you personally right now. Otherwise, there is a danger of raising pacifists or helpless victims instead of defenders of freedom. However, it is not such a great danger, since a parent is never solely responsible for upbringing. And that is a good thing.

2024, results

The statistics bot sent over the usual postcard about how the channel is doing. It is evident that it has grown slightly, which is due to a couple of cross-promotion campaigns organized by the magazine Fronda, for which I am grateful. I write an author’s column in that magazine, and I hope that for some, this will be a reason to subscribe to it. Another ongoing collaboration this year is writing articles for thematic collections in the magazine “Yozh“.

This year, I completed two long-term projects: the translation of David Friedman’s book “Legal Systems Very Different from Our Own“, as well as Eric Mack’s “Libertarianism” (and also Balaji Srinivasan’s “The Network State“, which by my standards didn’t quite reach “long-term project” status, although the translation did drag on quite a bit). In 2025, I expect to finish the last long-term project — Stephan Mol liqueur’s “Practical Anarchy“, and I will think thrice before taking on anything new. I am writing my own book, “Libertarian Theory of War“, terribly slowly, and the finish line is not yet in sight.

My personal discovery of the year was the website “Anarchonomicon“, run by a Canadian catgirl, pagan, white racist, and connoisseur of violent methods of problem solving — everything we libertarians value and are inspired by. An indirect result of this was me creating a Substack account, although so far I only read there; I haven’t dared to write or comment yet.

In Montelibero, I help promote the ideas of decentralization by participating in the movement to attract P2P investments into local businesses, as well as in organizing Tikhiy Omut — a libertarian club owned by its members. My contribution to filling the decentralized directory https://monte.wiki/ and the decentralized social network BSN is still completely insufficient, but I hope to increase it over time. I am also slowly adding Montenegro to OSM maps.

I hope that this year I have been a good girl and deserve some gifts.

I congratulate all readers on a year in which there should clearly be a global turn toward greater freedom. Stay on trend, join promising endeavors, promote your own projects, grow wealthy, and assert yourselves. A successful ideology deserves successful carriers!

A little more about folk dances

Several remarks were made regarding the previous post. As a rule, they ignored the fact that the post was an answer to the question “what do I think about the idea of masking military training with all sorts of harmless simulations?” and assumed that I was answering the question “how to secretly create an army from the state” or “how to secretly upgrade personal self-defense skills from the state.” My answer boiled down to the fact that if one is going to practice something like that, one should at least mask modern military affairs, rather than the tricks of the century before last, not to mention even more archaic ones.

The most famous case where people, under conditions of a ban on armament, masked military training with folk dances, was given the name “Boxer Rebellion” by Europeans. The rebellion was moderately effective against its own government, but not against the advanced foreign powers that intervened in the fray.

No one doubts that a small volunteer army, even a highly motivated one, will be completely helpless in field battles against even slightly competent state troops possessing heavy weaponry, especially long-range weaponry, especially high-precision weaponry, and especially if these troops are indifferent to causing collateral damage. But the point is not about armies in general, but about individuals.

First, someone who has mastered the skills of using various types of drones is already in a position to wage their own personal guerrilla war against personal enemies, whether they be government officials or private individuals. Explosive devices suitable for dropping from drones or attaching to FPVs are available for purchase in small quantities on the darknet or through other methods used by local gangs for their own skirmishes. We might simply not recognize a modern-day Gavrilo Princip, because he would have no need to approach within identification distance to use his weapon.

Second, in a situation where you decide to assist a state defending against an external invasion, what would you prefer to answer at the recruitment point where you go to sign up as a volunteer? “I am a good shooter” or “I am a good drone pilot”? Which answer will allow you to live longer and be of more use?

There is no doubt that folk dances are beautiful, and even a little useful, but they are very wasteful

Throughout human history, there have been many instances where an unfree part of society turned tools of labor into weapons and masked forbidden training as ritual dances. What does Ankap-chan think of this practice in relation to our time and gun control laws?

Moskvich

There is no more useful weaponized hobby for libertarians of all ages today than model aircraft clubs, drone piloting competitions, and similar completely harmless things. In Montelibero, there are already talks that a shooting club is, of course, a pleasant hobby, but how about teaching children to fly? Children are already learning this, of course, but not systematically enough; the ritual dances need further development.

Another useful type of ritual dance is the creative application of such a convenient agricultural tool as artificial intelligence. When a flying buzzing box autonomously combs through the mountains, finds a person lying in an inconspicuous crack, and carefully drops something useful to them—say, a first aid kit or a bottle of rakia, so they can tidy themselves up and hold out until rescuers arrive—that is extremely in demand for Montenegro. And why autonomously? Because in the mountains, you can’t ensure a stable radio signal; the slopes work no worse than some kind of EW device, such is the misfortune.

As for the harsh Olympic disciplines passed down from our ancestors, such as javelin throwing, we will leave those to the statists; let them continue preparing for the last war.

This girl is a bad dancer; you should look at the screen, not at the drone.

Libertarian Theory of War, Section 2.2. Entering the War

After a very long pause, I am continuing work on the book Libertarian Theory of War (thanks for the inspiration to the Canadian catgirl). The new section Entering the War is dedicated to an overview of the reasons for entering a war and the reasons for not entering one. As usual, spirits frolic on the pages of the book alongside economic analysis.

In the next chapter, in theory, the real meat should begin, as the preparations for the main action have dragged on a bit.

Translation of Eric Mack’s book “Libertarianism” is finished

The translation of the final chapter has been posted on my website. This chapter addresses a set of objections to libertarianism from well-meaning lovers of that wonderful atmosphere of cooperation and equality that we value so much in small communities united by a common goal. Eric Mack’s counterarguments boil down to the fact that attempting to stretch the “owl” of small, ideologically homogeneous communities over the “globe” of a diverse humanity leads to the owl tearing: the very values for which people cling to these small communities are lost.

Now only a purely technical task remains—to format the translation into an epub for more convenient reading. Those interested may use the text to publish a print run of hard copies of the translation on paper. I will be satisfied if, in doing so, it is indicated where the text was taken from, and a link is provided for those wishing to donate to the translator.

Anarchonomicon, review

An anonymous person asked me what I thought of a certain Canadian catgirl with the strange name Kulak (must be Ukrainian roots) who runs the website Anarchonomicon. I went to take a look and got hooked for a week)))

The website has two large, gradually expanding sections: Truly Banned Books and The Warlord’s Library. And besides that — a blog with regular notes.

Truly Banned Books

On what principle does Kulak select books as truly banned? Texts end up there for which people are assigned real prison sentences for possessing. Texts whose authors destroyed their careers by publishing them or were even killed for it. Texts that are not reprinted despite clear demand, becoming bibliographical rarities. Texts that are not cited. These can be puritanical and pornographic, racist and anti-racist, communist and fascist, written by dissidents and presidents alike. The main unifying feature is that the authors did not write them for a resume checkbox or for profit — but out of a need to speak out, even in the face of possible sanctions. It is for this sincerity that our catgirl singles them out from the general mass of literature.

The Warlord’s Library

A very impressive selection of materials on creating an armed formation, motivating it, managing it, and conducting military operations in various aspects (among other things, there is a link to David Friedman’s “The Machinery of Freedom,” the translation of which I published relatively recently). What were the main principles guiding the author of this selection?

First, most readers likely have no idea what kind of conflict, and of what specific sort, they will suddenly be involved in. Therefore, simply training one specific skill, such as shooting, is not enough. But training all the skills that could be useful in various conflicts is unrealistic. However, mastering the literature on the subject is quite realistic. The vast majority of military conflicts are waged by non-professionals.

Second, the best book is the one you actually read. As long as it is just lying somewhere online, there is little use for it. But in the event of an approaching real conflict, you can at least go into an already prepared selection and read exactly the materials that seem relevant, if for some reason they were not mastered in advance.

Blog

Unfortunately, Kulak is somewhat shaky on technical issues related to the Ukrainian war, but when it comes to broader analysis, her thoughts are quite interesting. For example, the post on violence, dedicated to the recent murder of an insurance tycoon, is rhetorically very strong, although it does raise some questions from the perspective of the Austrian School of economics.

In short, I’ve subscribed to the cat-girl, which required me to register on Substack. There is a possibility that I might even post a copy of my own notes on this platform, but it’s not very likely: paid publications there require using the Stripe system, which, in turn, requires linking a bank card—and if it’s neither Montenegrin nor Russian, they can go to hell. And it only makes sense to build up another platform for free publications if I start, say, writing in English.

Eric Mack. Libertarianism. Translation of the penultimate chapter, on the critique of property rights by Murphy and Nagel

After a long, terrifyingly long break, I am getting around to finishing my once-started translation projects. Today it is the penultimate chapter of Libertarianism by Eric Mack, in which the author examines the critique of libertarianism by certain individuals unknown to me, Murphy and Nagel. The main point of their critique is that no natural rights exist; all rights are a convention. And, since the existing system of property rights is established through a state funded by taxes, it is meaningless to speak of the injustice of taxation, because taxation is inextricably linked to the very existence of property rights. A curious judgment that should make any libertarian’s blood boil. The way Eric Mack responds to them will, of course, not satisfy these statists, but it may slightly soothe the libertarian heartache.

While the translation was on pause, the mysterious technologies of the ancients were completely forgotten, so there will be no image with a progress bar.

David Friedman. Legal Systems Very Different from Our Own. Publishing my translation

The translation of the book was started by Dima Kovalenko under the editorship of Vladimir Zolotorev. Then, several chapters were translated by me independently. Finally, the translation was completed by order of the Socium publishing house. On the publisher’s website, you can purchase both the paper and electronic versions of the text. About six months have passed since the translation was published—plenty of time to sell a certain number of copies and recoup the project. So now I am publishing on my own page the original version of the translation, before its editing by the publisher. The translation is available for reading online; I will not be making an epub, as a downloadable version is already on sale.

The book is not about libertarianism, but about the competition of legal systems, and about the fact that no ideal legal system exists—there are many different conflicts occurring in many different circumstances, and inquisitive human thought invents very interesting ways to resolve them.

I also remind you that I still have a couple of translation projects remaining: “Libertarianism” by Eric Mack and “Practical Anarchy” by Stephan Molynieux. I think it’s time to finish these texts, and the best way to speed up the process is through your donations. By the way, Stephan Molynieux’s film was shown at the MTL-Fest 2024 pre-party, and after it ended, the viewers had the opportunity to chat briefly with the author; those interested can watch the recording of this conversation on the MTL-TV channel.

What should a libertarian do in emigration?

I suggested this topic to Mikhail Svetov for his presentation at MTL Fest 2023, but he preferred to talk about how one should think about global things and build a libertarian international. While preparing for MTL Fest 2024, I suggested giving Mikhail Pozharsky the topic “What should a libertarian do in Russia,” but he talked about why emigration is disgraceful, and that everyone who leaves the country makes things worse for those who remain. Perhaps it is better for me to reflect on the subject myself rather than continue pestering famous bloggers; they have already said what they wanted to say.

There are common notes in the reasoning of both Michaels. Svetov reminds us that a political emigrant is a refugee, usually poor, having lost everything in their homeland, and they should not feel safe in a new place; on the contrary, they should cling to the worldview of “I am at war” to stay sharp, to stay angry, and to be ready to stand by their own and avenge their enemies. Pozharsky speaks of lost emigrants who, after moving to another country, continue to cringe-worthily live by their old political agendas just to give themselves some sense of being needed and some semblance of meaning to their lives.

I extremely dislike both how Pozharsky describes emigrants and how Svetov wants to see them. In my view, a libertarian is a person with a developed sense of self-respect, capable of integrating organically into the market, valuing voluntary cooperation, and knowing that it is entrepreneurs who drive the world forward. The function of a libertarian is to prosper peacefully, preserve their property, and serve as an example for everyone who also wants to become a person of dignity.

Even when fleeing from an old country to a new one in haste and without possessions, a libertarian should not feel it as “I am a victim, I have lost everything.” No, he has successfully closed a dead-end project and immediately proceeded to implement a new one, taking into account the accumulated experience. Should he focus entirely on his own settlement? If necessary, during the most critical stage of his new life project—then yes. As soon as the opportunity arises, it is important to immediately lift one’s head above current chores, look around, establish or refresh friendly and business contacts, and contemplate one’s new position in a broader context.

Should one reject everything that was left behind in Russia or whichever country the emigrant arrived from? Again, not to reject, but to rethink. One could, for example, not just follow how things are going in the Russo-Ukrainian war, but choose a specific brigade, donate to them for supplies, and then proudly tell loved ones, “Look how fiercely my brigade is fighting.” Or, for instance, instead of participating in pathetic election campaigns somewhere on the edge of the earth, simply appoint oneself a deputy right here, in the diaspora, and gain experience in real affairs, earning real authority. The state is out there somewhere, but society is right here. We are all individualists; we form society, rather than bowing to the state like some pathetic collectivists.