The Westphalian state, panarchy, and ancap using IT as an example

Column of Bitarch

Three main types of system organization can be identified: centralized, decentralized, and distributed. This applies to all complex systems with multiple nodes, both technological and social. In a centralized system, there is a single point of control (a server) through which all interaction of regular nodes (clients) occurs, both with the server itself and with each other. In a decentralized system, there is no single server; instead, there is a certain number of super-nodes connected to other super-nodes as well as to clients (client-to-client interaction occurs with the participation of super-nodes). In a distributed system, the network is entirely peer-to-peer, and clients interact with each other directly, without any intermediary.

Let’s consider the history of the Internet. In its early days, if you wanted to distribute a file to other people, you had to upload it to your own server (Web, FTP), from where anyone interested could then download it. As the flow of visitors increased, your server might fail to handle the load, or the bandwidth of the communication channel could be exhausted, which ultimately made downloading the file impossible. I don’t think it’s necessary to mention the extreme vulnerability of such a system to a “forceful” server shutdown—that should be obvious.

Later, decentralized file-sharing systems appeared, such as Kazaa, eDonkey, and BitTorrent. These no longer had a central server that could easily fail. User interaction occurred through many independent super-nodes (for example, torrent trackers), which provided file search and coordination of data regarding the availability of files on regular users’ computers. For greater resilience and improved quality of service, fully peer-to-peer (distributed) networks later emerged, such as BitTorrent with DHT, which can operate without a torrent tracker at all, or the InterPlanetary File System (IPFS) on the blockchain, which is fully resistant to censorship and individual node failure.

Decided to create your own internet resource? You’re in luck! Today there is a sea of options for hosting it. A quarter of a century ago, it would have been significantly more difficult. Back then, you needed to possess a huge sum of money to buy a physical server, place it in a room with a high-speed Internet connection, powerful power supply, cooling, etc. It is not surprising that there were practically no individual online projects at that time.

The boom of the Internet coincided with the appearance of virtualization technology, which allowed several virtual machines (VMs) to run on one physical server simultaneously. For example, there are the well-known VirtualBox and VMware. Each virtual machine allowed it to be treated as a physical server, solving the problem of running several applications simultaneously (each may require its own versions of system libraries and OS settings, so running them simultaneously under one OS could create a conflict).

The number of applications grew, but the ability of a physical server to run VMs is limited by memory and disk space. A solution emerged—containerization—virtualization at the operating system level (e.g., Docker). It uses the shared kernel of the physical server’s operating system, and each container encapsulates only the application itself, the required versions of libraries, and specific OS settings (rather than a full OS, as in a VM). This allows for a significant reduction in the size of the container image compared to a VM (which makes it easier to move from server to server), and also reduces the load on the physical server (meaning more applications can be run on it, lowering the price for end users).

How does all of this relate to social organization? Currently, we live in a fully centralized state with a territorial monopoly (the so-called Westphalian state) and constantly encounter it. As in the previous example with different versions of system libraries for different applications, different people have different values, religions, and ideas about life. It is complete absurdity to believe that, for example, Turks and Kurds can live by the same laws! And, as we see, any attempts by the Turkish authorities to impose uniform rules are met with resistance, up to armed struggle.

The simplest solution in this situation seems to be a transition to a decentralized system in the form of panarchy (a system of contractual jurisdictions – CJ), where each group with shared views has its own government, not tied to a territory. Some libertarians may not like this option, as they want to choose “components” on the market entirely according to their own tastes and not depend on a CJ. This results in a fully distributed model, which we call anarcho-capitalism (ancap).

History has many examples of transitioning from a centralized system to a decentralized one, and then to a distributed one. Here is another example—electronic media. First, there was fully centralized radio and television, then came the decentralized Internet with websites, and only now are the sprouts of fully distributed applications appearing (such as Bitcoin, or Ethereum with smart contracts). I cannot even provide examples of a transition from a centralized system directly to a distributed one (bypassing the decentralized), so I consider such a thing extremely unlikely. This also applies to social organization, and it is naive to believe that we can move directly from a centralized state (even a minarchist one) to ancap. I provided practical arguments in my article “Realistic Libertarianism”.

Realistic Libertarianism

Column Bitarch

When reading people’s opinions on the ideas of anarcho-capitalism (ancap), one can often hear that it is a “utopia,” “escapism,” a “fantasy world,” a “fandom,” and that libertarianism itself is a “sect,” a “cult,” or an “ideology for rich hipsters.” It is obvious that while the ideology of ancap is consistent and theoretically feasible, convincing the vast majority of people of this is quite difficult, if possible at all. Attempting to transition to ancap via minarchism, as proposed by one of the leaders of the LPR, Mikhail Svetov, is also a dead end—the instability of minarchism has been proven both theoretically and empirically through numerous historical examples.

Besides the well-known division of libertarianism into ancap and minarchism, there is another ideology that could also be called quasi-libertarian: panarchy. It appeared more than a century before Rothbard’s ideas, when in 1860, the Belgian scholar Paul Émile de Puydt wrote a pamphlet titled “Panarchy” (“pan” and “archy” meaning “power of all,” “omnipotence”) [1]. During his lifetime, he did not attempt to promote this idea, and it was only remembered in the 21st century with the growing popularity of libertarianism and blockchain technologies.

Panarchy does not aim for the complete destruction of the state, but advocates for the abolition of its territorial monopoly and for voluntary participation in it. In short—laws should apply to people, not to territory. If you dislike something, you can choose another ETC without leaving the country. You can also find like-minded people and create your own ETC with your desired laws.

Other names for this ideology are extraterritorial contractual jurisdictions (ETC, sometimes just CJ), extraterritorial state, insurance state, umbrella states, poly-state, multi-government, FOCJ, cellular statehood, virtual cantons, modular state.

Cellular Statehood

In this article, I will attempt to provide arguments in favor of panarchy over ancap and minarchism, based on the criterion of the realism of implementing the theory in the real world. Pure Rothbardian ancap with the absolute non-aggression principle, of course, seems more attractive to libertarians, but it must be understood that its realization could take a long time and exceed the planning horizon of each of us.

Panarchy solves most of the problems inherent in ancap and minarchism, which are often used as criticisms against libertarians and complicate the promotion of libertarianism to the masses.

1. Social Protection

Although libertarians propose private insurance and charity as solutions, statists put forward a quite strong counter-argument, upon hearing which many people turn away from libertarian ideas: “What if a person is poor, cannot buy insurance, has no friends, and no one wants to help them? Are they left only to starve to death?”. In my observation, this is the most common objection to libertarianism, applying to both ancap and minarchism.

In panarchy, such people can choose a socialist ETC and receive social protection exactly as they do now from the state, paying voluntary contributions (“taxes”) to their ETC. This applies to all services of modern states—education, healthcare, the pension system, social insurance, security, and fire protection.

2. Public Spaces

We are used to leaving our apartments into a “public space” that belongs to no one and therefore cannot be “locked” for us. Ancaps, however, say that everything should be private, meaning that from your own territory you would step onto someone else’s. And the owner is essentially omnipotent, meaning they could simply forbid you from entering their property, effectively locking you in your own. This is a slightly contrived example, but somewhat frightening: private roads, forests, fields, seas—and the owner is an absolute ruler. It scares me. Furthermore, it is unclear how to privatize what is currently common; it is too conflict-prone a process. How do you privatize a street in Moscow to account for all interests and offend no one, without infringing on anyone’s “common rights”? I believe privatization is impossible due to the conflict-prone nature of the process and the fears associated with it. I am more inclined toward flexible forms where there is room for easements and common law, where not everything becomes private, remaining common/no-man’s-land. [2]

3. Defense

An argument often raised against ancap is that a stateless territory would quickly be seized by highly organized states with powerful military-industrial complexes. In reality, this is not the case, and a well-organized decentralized defense is capable of resisting even a strong opponent [3], making the residents of that territory an “unprofitable victim” for the aggressor.

Panarchy combines both the advantages of decentralized defense found in ancap and the resource-technological capabilities of a state [4], including for the creation of weapons that maintain peace through a deterrence doctrine (for example, ballistic missiles and stealth kamikaze drones, ensuring a high probability of destroying the enemy’s decision-makers who initiate aggression).

4. Popularity of the Idea of Freedom

If you ask a group of ordinary people “Which values are most important to you?”, the ideals of freedom will be far from the first place. Classical-liberal (minarchist) parties have existed in Europe for a long time, yet they have never achieved great success in elections. Even the most powerful class-lib party in Europe—the Swiss FDP.Die Liberalen—has garnered only 15-20% of the vote for many decades. [5]

Panarchy, instead of abstract ideas of freedom that are poorly understood by the majority, promotes the possibility of living by rules and cooperating with people you have chosen yourself without coercion (unlike modern states, where you are obliged to obey the will of the majority, even if you disagree with it). Another argument is the increase in the efficiency of state services through competition (in modern monopoly states, people clearly see how their taxes are wasted).

5. Default Choice

States usually provide standardization of product quality, testing of drug efficacy, some kind of standard for universal school education, basic emergency medical care and fire protection (available to all, regardless of purchasing insurance), protection of labor rights, and various “one-stop-shop” services. Many people do not want (or do not have the possibility for objective reasons) to spend their time studying millions of different offers on the market and prefer to receive some sort of default option.

6. Unified Understanding of NAP

Among libertarians, there are constant disputes about the permissibility of abortions, the age of sexual consent, the sale of drugs, contractual slavery, and some other issues arising from different understandings of the Non-Aggression Principle (NAP) among different people. Attempting to impose a single standard for everyone only leads to the rejection of libertarian ideas. In panarchy, each ETC can have its own understanding of acceptable norms. People and businesses may choose not to cooperate with citizens of other ETCs in certain areas of life if they diverge strongly from the norms of their own ETC. Also, if a person strongly diverges from the values of their ETC, they can seek protection from another ETC and transition to it, if they are accepted (analogous to refugee status in a modern state, which is unclear how it would operate under ancap).

7. Painless Relinquishing of Power for Government Members

The transition to panarchy can happen completely painlessly for the current authorities—a “fork” (parallel government) is created, and economic entities (schools, hospitals, state enterprises, road services, universities, etc.) will be able to choose which one to join (they can switch to another ETC at any moment if they wish) [6]. In this case, the members of the government currently in power in a centralized state will remain in power in the first formed ETC and need not fear for their personal safety. Otherwise, the lack of guarantees of inviolability greatly complicates the change of power, as the current authorities will fight to the end, knowing the fate that awaits them in the event of a violent overthrow.

8. A Clear Transition Scenario

In many countries, there is currently a strong polarization of society, as in the USA, where the division in values between supporters of Democrats and Republicans has reached a historical maximum [7]. This has a strong destabilizing effect on the government (its members are constantly unable to agree on most issues among themselves) and creates fertile ground for the formation of ETCs “from below.” For the “top-down” authority, this is also beneficial, as it minimizes the probability of a bloody revolution and reprisals against its members, as described in the previous point. Other scenarios are considered in the blog of the well-known “evangelist” of the idea of panarchy, Oleg
“Laxy Catal” Tarakanov [8].

9. Presence of Many Examples of Panarchy

Ancaps are often asked: name countries where anarcho-capitalism was or is? Aside from the well-known examples of medieval Iceland and Ireland, there is usually nothing to say. Extraterritorial jurisdictions, however, have existed for almost all of known history—these are the early (before the reforms of Cleisthenes in Attica) Greek poleis, medieval universities, religious orders, guilds and craft associations, millets in the Ottoman Empire, and partly pillarization in Holland until the mid-20th century. The modern Order of Malta, having no territory of its own, is essentially an extraterritorial state [9]. What’s more, even now diplomats of all countries in the world, according to international agreements, live under conditions of panarchy! [10]. And since the model is already well-tested, nothing prevents its large-scale implementation. The principle “all are equal before the law” could actually start working, whereas now it remains only in official declarations.

10. Compatibility with Ancap

Although panarchy looks like a retreat from ancap principles, it may nevertheless turn out to be a quite realistic precursor to it. Participation in an ETC is voluntary; accordingly, the evolutionary process will gradually weed out those that are inconvenient for clients and leave those that best satisfy the ideals of freedom.

Sources

  1. Paul Émile de Puydt “Panarchy“, trans. Egor Liskin
  2. Oleg Tarakanov “Fundamental Problems of Anarcho-Capitalism”
  3. Vladimir Zolotorev “Insurance Company Sonechko vs. the Tsardom of Muscovy”
  4. Oleg Tarakanov “Not Ancap: The Difference Between Extraterritorial States and Private Security Companies”
  5. Wikipedia “FDP.The Liberals”
  6. Anatoly Levenchuk “Providers of Cellular Statehood”
  7. Pew Research Center “Political Polarization in the American Public”
  8. Oleg Tarakanov “Insurance States (Part 2)”
  9. Wikipedia “Order of Malta”
  10. Wikipedia “Diplomatic Immunity”