Please provide a philosophical analysis of this video

In particular, about freedom, property, voluntary interaction, and the boundaries of individual autonomy

https://rt.pornhub.com/view_video.php?viewkey=ph6075cd75089c4

Nihilist (the question is accompanied by a donation of 0.00012 BTC)

The question has puzzled me quite a bit, but what can you do. The money has been paid – I have to answer.

In the video, an OnlyFans model plays a dominance game with her partner: she straps him to the bed, straddles him, and forces him to cum inside her, while he breaks down like a girl, saying something like, “Can you do it without creampieing? I’m not in the mood today.”

In these times, the situation is completely ordinary. Generated videos have not yet displaced live filming. Marriage and children in no way interfere with self-expression on OnlyFans, especially since they are behind the scenes. Simple role-playing in bed is a common seasoning for sex, especially if it is for an audience.

In short, what we have before us in no way violates libertarian principles, nor mainstream liberal norms. In Montenegro, I crossed paths three times with girls who worked in the adult-content industry: one at the beach, another during a medical exam, and a third also worked as a DJ. They did not hide their occupation, were not ashamed at all, and in the companies they hung out with, it wasn’t a sensation at all. Just another type of remote work. If people were interested in anything regarding their work, it was how much it cost to provide themselves with a sufficiently wide and stable outgoing internet channel. I cannot rule out that men perceived their occupation with somewhat more caution; it’s hard for me to judge here. At least, I happened to overhear the indignation of some guy whose acquaintance offered him to work as a second person in the frame, and he’d rather die than do such a thing—he was just hitting on her purely and selflessly, and was, of course, stunned that he was perceived more as a candidate for business partners than as a romantic suitor.

Nearly a third of Alex Rozov’s book volume is a condemnation of various forms of puritanism, and while reading them, I have always found it unclear where he gets so many puritans from and why he devotes so much attention to them; it would be just like if I started angrily condemning some form of classical Marxism in every second post—an obviously marginal ideology at the moment, whose peak of influence has long since passed. In short, no matter how you look at it, it is unclear what is so special about this video that it warrants discussion.

However, we can view it specifically as a short fiction film. In that case, we are interested not in the actress herself, but in the act of her character, who chained a man to a bed to forcibly conceive a child from him. In this case, indeed, the act itself becomes a violation of the non-aggression principle, and most likely, it is a prologue to an even greater violation of the non-aggression principle. The most probable motive for such an unusual offense is the desire to secure alimony (otherwise, there are no problems with obtaining consent, and thus no coercion is required; for example, I had no problems finding the father of my child). In this scenario, the man must be wealthy enough that such an adventure makes sense for the sake of alimony, and harmless enough that scenarios of coercing him to abandon his criminal intent are not taken seriously. Well, in that case, what we have before us is an illustration of a criminal conspiracy between a petty extortionist and a serious gang. In fact, it is the same scenario as a classic robbery, in which a small boy first appears on the scene, provokes the victim into rudeness, and that is when the muscle appears to collect for the rudeness. Is it worth taking offense at the boy in this scenario? It is clear that the main problem lies with the gang. It is the same with alimony—the problem lies with the state.

Of course, this does not mean that if there were no gangs, everyone would bully the little boys, or that if there were no state, there would be no one to care for the unfortunate woman left alone with a child in her arms while the father vanished into the sunset. It simply means that the process of resolving such situations would become far more varied than the typical statist scenario of appealing to the toughest bully in the neighborhood.

These are, perhaps, the philosophical considerations that this mediocre pornographic video is capable of prompting in me.

Freedom of speech and the First Amendment — are they a blessing?

Bitarch’s Column

Among libertarians, there is a firm belief that the existence of freedom of speech in a country based on the principle of the American First Amendment to the Constitution is an unambiguous benefit that helps us fight statism. But is this actually the case, or is it a cleverly planned trap that has helped the US ruling elites avoid revolutions for almost two and a half centuries?

Let’s look at the fate of well-known anti-statists in the US who began to pose any significant threat to the state. Jim Bell, the creator and evangelist of the “assassination market” idea, was imprisoned for “tax evasion.” Larken Rose, a well-known ancap, also ended up behind bars for taxes. I think there is no need to remind everyone of the story with Julian Assange and the sexual allegations; everyone knows it already.

What conclusion can be drawn from this? If your words pose a real danger to the stationary bandit, a pretext for repression will always be found; it is not necessary for him to repress specifically for words. What do you think will happen if a full-page advertisement is printed in the New York Times with the text “The State is a stationary bandit! Panarchy is the primary path to freedom!”? I am willing to bet that the next day the FBI will find child pornography or drugs in the possession of the activist who ordered such an ad. Or it will turn out that he likes to abuse his dog and is generally not opposed to eating it. Unfortunately, most active fighters against the state in the US do not understand this.

In Russia, the situation is completely different. The authorities repress directly for politics, and they don’t even disguise it particularly well. We have convenient “extremism” articles with extremely vague content, allowing anyone to be imprisoned for anything, so there is no need to bother planting child pornography on an activist. Because of this, all active fighters against the state use VPNs, burner SIMs, encryption, and intermediaries from the very beginning of their activities, and they never show their faces. As a result, in terms of the difficulty of capture, such an activist is equal to a professional hacker, so it is easier to earn medals by searching for extremism on VKontakte. The investigator is not concerned with the fact that a real fighter against the state can indeed be dangerous to the state: that is not his level of responsibility. The more pressure the authorities apply, the more anonymization methods the fighters against the state will use, and the faster its territorial monopoly will be destroyed. The same cannot be said for countries where people still believe in freedom of speech.

Ancap-chan’s Commentary

Yesterday, Ved Neuman released an article in which he responded to a comment by Laksi Katal regarding the deadlock of the “butt-end”: the lighter the power, the more willingly people surrender to it.

As we can see, opinions are divided on what is more beneficial for supporters of the total abolition of the state—an openly repressive state that discredits itself, or its liberalization, with a potential increase in the level of trust in it. Bitarch and Laksi Katal believe that the principle of “the worse, the better” works: the worse the state, the easier it is to convince people that it is not needed at all. Following Ved, I believe that appetite comes with eating, and once one starts pushing back the state, one will not want to stop, especially if life actually improves at every stage of the reforms. This is especially relevant in countries that lack a developed culture of respect for the opposition, where the custom is to finish off the opponent. Once the state begins to bend, they will finish it off.

So it seems strange to me to consider it a bad thing if the state has to seek indirect paths for repression because the direct path is blocked. On the contrary, this is merely a reason to block those very indirect paths. Freedom of speech exists—it must be used to stop persecution for victimless crimes, such as possession of child pornography or drug use, and any flailing of the state in this regard should be used to incite hatred toward the institution itself, which, instead of trying to justify its existence with whatever useful things, continues to insist on its right to repress a wide circle of persons on its own initiative, without a request from victims.

The brief essence of our discussion