Why the achievement of voluntary free relationships is impossible in a society where too many people are capable of committing violence

Voluntarist, Bitarch

There is a view that the only essential condition for achieving freedom of activity, agreement, and association is the creation of significant costs for criminals. Allegedly, it is sufficient that any harm inevitably requires compensation, and that everyone owns weapons, which would make attacks unprofitable (do not think that we are against gun ownership – it is useful for evolutionary selection, but right now we are talking about something else). In such a case, even if everyone were a psychopath, significant violence would not arise in practice. Moreover, some might say that aggressiveness is even necessary for a free person, for example, to easily kill for any encroachments upon oneself and to carry out violent revenge (on the principle of “an eye for an eye”). But we can easily dispute this position and prove why freedom is possible only in a society of peaceful people.

First, it would be foolish to believe that people always act rationally and accurately assess benefits and risks. Even in societies where fingers and hands were cut off for theft, thieves did not disappear completely. This is even more true for psychopathic individuals. As research shows, they concentrate too heavily on their goals, missing important details. For example, in a task where they had to navigate a maze by manipulating levers and avoiding those that delivered painful electric shocks, they handled the first condition well, but were worse than ordinary people at the second. In gambling, they were poor at learning long-term strategies; it was important for them to quickly hit a huge win, even at the risk of putting themselves in the negative. Likewise, psychopathic pilots in World War II would easily chase an enemy, forgetting to monitor fuel, the position of other aircraft, and other factors critical for victory.

Understanding this, would anyone still think that psychopathic individuals can be reasoned with or intimidated enough to ensure they definitely do not commit violence, do not organize criminal gangs, or even avoid trying to forcibly subjugate everyone and create their own power in a society where none exists? Let us not forget that current states arose precisely through the violent subjugation of people. And striving for the position of a “stationary” bandit, “nomadic” bandits ignored the risk of death at the hands of defenders and their competitors.

Second, there are many ways to cause harm to people without direct violence. Various kinds of manipulations, including gossip, blackmail, threats, pitting people against each other, provoking a hostile reaction (to make you look unstable to others), wearing someone down, psychological and economic violence, etc., which are often used by psychopaths in the pursuit of their own benefit. It will be impossible to write deterrent factors and punishments for all such scenarios. This means that the more psychopathic individuals there are around, the more such manipulations will be applied to you personally, and instead of productive activity, you will spend all your time defending yourself from attempts to walk all over you. Also, psychopathic individuals are prone to sabotaging collective work for personal gain.

Now imagine the opposite situation – psychopathic individuals are absent or negligibly few. In such a society, freedom of relationships would occur instantly and without additional requirements. At the same time, in a society of psychopaths, one could likely expect something similar to what is currently happening in Haiti or the scenario of the movie “New World,” where rapists sent to live on an island organized a mass slaughter, and at some point, a small portion of them even forcibly subjugated all the others and monopolized the possession of resources. And if you would not want to participate daily in a war of all against all in a “free” society, you should first think about eradicating such a pathology as the dysfunction of the violence inhibition mechanism, which makes some people psychopathically predisposed and capable of easily causing harm to other people.

Can psychopaths experience empathy and how does it differ from the empathy of normal people

Voluntarist, Bitarch

It is a commonly held opinion that psychopathic individuals experience little empathy or do not manifest it at all. This, of course, makes them cold-blooded and callous, capable even of easily committing murder if there is a reason for it and no significant risks. But besides this, their lack of empathy has long cast doubt on the possibility of providing easy and effective therapy for their condition.

However, a study of psychopathic criminals found that they can experience empathy. Moreover, during the experiment, they exhibited the same level of activation of mirror neurons—which are responsible for the ability to learn through imitation of other people and are believed to be involved in the manifestation of empathy—as healthy individuals.

However, psychopaths have one very important difference. While empathy manifests spontaneously in normal people, regardless of whether the person wishes to experience it, psychopaths can intentionally control this process. Their normal state is switched-off empathy; they manifest it only when they want to. And within the experiment, normal activation of mirror neurons in psychopaths was observed only when the researchers explicitly asked them to show empathy.

The results of this study align with what psychopaths often claim about themselves, for example, on question-and-answer websites like Quora. If you search there for questions asked to psychopaths about whether they are capable of experiencing empathy, you will see many positive answers, but with the note that they can literally turn empathy on and off whenever they want, as if they have a switch for it. However, there are also psychopaths who claim a complete inability to feel empathy. But, given the data already known to us, it can be suggested that they simply do not know how to turn it on within themselves.

Researchers do not yet know how to turn the empathy that psychopaths can manifest intentionally into the spontaneously manifested empathy characteristic of most people. However, the fact that psychopaths can show empathy, at least under certain conditions, gives therapists something to work with.

It is also worth hypothesizing that empathy can be made spontaneous quite easily by using certain agents that activate specific serotonin receptors and favorably influence the function of the serotonin system as a whole. Pharmacological activation of serotonin 1A and 1B receptors in animal experiments often leads to them ceasing aggressive attacks on their peers, or even becoming more predisposed to help them—for example, by sharing food, even if it brings the subject no personal benefit. This effect is linked to the activation of a violence inhibition mechanism, which in humans plays an important role in the development of empathy.

The results of this study provide an answer to another important question. Someone might easily find and point to individuals who, in their ordinary social life, are normal family men, good friends and colleagues, law-abiding citizens—that is, full members of society—despite the fact that under certain conditions, for example, while serving in law enforcement or as a soldier on the battlefield, they easily committed violence and even murder without feeling the slightest repulsion. As is known from a number of studies, including military ones, the ability to easily commit violence and murder in such conditions would still be a manifestation of an individual’s high psychopathy. But there is no contradiction here. For perhaps such cases are precisely explainable by the fact that psychopathic individuals can be empathic when they intentionally want to be, for example, wishing to have a full social life. However, it should not be forgotten that such individuals can decide not to experience empathy at any moment, and this carries certain threats to society.

Network State, Chapter 4.3. Techno-economic Axes.

Happy St. Patrick’s Day to everyone, and at the same time, happy end of Maslenitsa; and to those who love filming queues in fast-forward mode—happy opportunity to indulge in your favorite pastime. So many holidays in one day—isn’t that great, isn’t that panarchy!

As for me, another chapter of The Network State has been quietly translated. Balaji Srinivasan continues to discuss the trends of the near future, and if in the previous chapter he discussed socio-political trends, now he touches upon the techno-economic consequences of the digitalization and internetization of everything.

For instance, he notes that the sharp lowering of the publishing threshold increases variance: alongside traditional, polished, and weighted but uninteresting positions, a multitude of the most unusual chthonic entities crawl into the light. And besides the shaking of discourse via social networks, there is also the shaking of financial stability through countless cryptocurrencies.

Another interesting aspect discussed by the author is that the total digitalization of everything leads to digital entities becoming primary, while physical ones, in essence, materialize on demand if there is a need.

He also briefly touches upon the mystery of why we do not observe as frantic a leap in productivity in the physical world as we do in the digital world. Then, providing a whole brood of hypotheses, he suggests choosing between them independently.

In short, the chapter is quite saturated with ideas and generalizations, so I don’t see much point in summarizing it; it’s easier to just read it.

Another attempt to recommend the Monteliberal YouTube channel to you

While the channel is on vacation, I’m not bothering with original materials, but so you don’t get bored, I’ll be posting some external content from time to time.

Soz recorded and posted a very high-quality video on MTL-TV, where he explains why the use of multi-signature wallets is extremely useful for literally everyone who holds large sums in cryptocurrencies, and how easily and conveniently this is organized in the Stellar blockchain in general and in the Montelibero tokenomics in particular. I highly recommend it, and I also want to use the suggested recipes once I have a bit more free time.

And don’t forget about the Ankaposhnaya segment on the same channel; they’ve already reached the part explaining the market and seem to have no intention of stopping.

How tears affect aggressiveness

Voluntarist, Bitarch

From the theory of the violence inhibition mechanism, we know that a healthy individual, when observing the suffering (distress signals) of another person, begins to experience a feeling of aversion and becomes predisposed to ceasing aggressive actions toward them. This effect is psychological; the neural pathways responsible for it are activated as a result of observing suffering as a social signal. At least, this is what we used to believe. However, some new discoveries indicate that the impact of certain distress signals on the violence inhibitor—specifically, crying—may be chemical in nature.

Several years ago, a study on rats revealed that rubbing female tears onto the face and other body parts of males, who played the role of “intruders” in the experiments, reduced the aggressiveness of the “residents”—the males whose cages they entered. Given that all necessary conditions of the resident-intruder paradigm are met, an aggressive attack by the resident on the intruder is expected. However, it was found that if the intruder smells of female tears, no aggression is shown toward them. At the same time, male tears do not possess this effect.

Recently, a similar result was reproduced in humans. To measure the aggressiveness of men, a money game was used involving provocations and the possibility to “get revenge” for them, without receiving any personal benefit from the revenge. Players were told they were playing against another person, although they were actually playing against a computer. Before the game, men were given 1 ml samples to smell 13 times at intervals of 35 seconds. The first three times it was a saline solution; the remaining ten were also saline solution for the control group and female tears for the experimental group.

As a result, aggressive gaming behavior (the desire to avenge provocations) in men who smelled female tears was 43.7% lower than in the control group. Additionally, MRI scans revealed that their prefrontal cortex and the anterior part of the insular cortex in the brain were not as strongly activated as a result of provocations during the game.

Of course, as psychologists note, certain questions may arise in real-life situations—for example, why tears, despite the remarkable results of the experiments, do not always play a significant role in stopping domestic violence. There is a suggestion that tears may not be significant in relationships between adults, and that the evolutionary role of their anti-aggressive effect is to protect children, who are unable to state that aggression must stop but will cry a lot if it occurs. Experiments with children’s tears are still planned. Research is also planned to find the specific component of tears that causes the anti-aggressive effect. This could help in the creation and production of a highly effective, humane means of self-defense that causes no harm to the attacker.

Perhaps the channel is going on vacation

Another translation order has come in, and it’s also quite urgent. This means I may need to take a break from running the channel.

Therefore, for now, I can recommend listening to the podcasts on our Montelibero channel MTL-TV, especially, of course, the new “Ankaposhnaya” section; it’s not so much about Montelibero as it is about various libertarian theories—after all, that’s why you gathered here to read, isn’t it?

Montelibero is a decentralized community, which is why the channel has no single host; it is managed by whoever needs it most at the moment. First it was Soz, then Birkin, now it’s Ivan from the Ogurism channel, and later perhaps someone else will take over.

Also, to keep from getting too bored, you can boost the channel for now. Previously, this would only have given me the ability to post stories, but I find it barbaric to work on content that is destined to disappear quickly—such is my vain nature. But now, a well-boosted channel can also be styled more exquisitely, and it’s better to have that option than not to have it.

Libertarian Theory of War, Section 2.1. Preparing for War

A substantial piece of text is ready for a book on the theory of war, covering various aspects of war preparation. It took a very long time to write; it is evident that excerpts from different periods differ in style, but I do not want to delay publication; I will still have time to proofread it.

Let us consider this as a substitute for the routine post on the anniversary of the beginning of the full-scale invasion of Ukrainian territory by Russian troops, and after all, I promised to speed up after Navalny’s death. So, I am speeding up.

Network State, Part 4. Decentralization, recentralization. Chapters 4.1 and 4.2

The translation of the fourth part of The Network State has begun. As expected, after finishing with the “past present,” the author has moved on to discussing the future.

In Chapter 4.1, Possible Versions of the Future, Balaji Srinivasan begins by clarifying the factors that prevent him from making precise forecasts, then provides a brief description of the envisioned future scenario, and finally estimates where his idea of network states would fit into this scenario. In doing so, he uses the disgustingly clumsy term “re-centralized center.” My ability to adapt the text during translation is limited, so I can only state that the term is terrible and difficult to understand, but nothing comes to mind yet to replace it with. What does the author even mean? As far as I can judge based on an incomplete reading, the word “center” refers to the center of the triangle he drew in the third part of the book describing a tripolar world—suggesting that our salvation lies in not falling into the extremes that accumulate at the poles. And he has yet to explain “re-centralized.” Perhaps it means that every startup community must have its own leader, otherwise it won’t take off. I would be glad to be wrong.

In Chapter 4.2, Sociopolitical Axes, the author briefly notes that to assess the future, it is not enough to look at well-known and long-established trends; it is also worth looking at those that are only just forming. As examples of sociopolitical factors that could seriously affect the future, he provides three completely diverse examples: Indians (while everyone is looking at China, India is quietly closing the gap, and in the next decade should make its presence felt quite loudly, both as a state and as a diaspora, i.e., a Network, in the author’s terminology), the confrontation between the “un-prime” and the “trans-hum” (Klaus Schwab was listed as a transhumanist), and the identity stack (there are several interesting thoughts on where identities come from, as well as a non-obvious take that one identity will inevitably be the leading and defining one).

The chapters in the fourth part of the book are not very long, so I will try to post them in groups rather than one by one, to avoid cluttering the feed.

What to do if you do not want to repeat Navalny’s fate

Voluntarist, Bitarch

In connection with what has happened, I would like to express my own opinion. Of course, many are grieving and expressing their condolences. However, now would be the time to talk about what this story can teach us. The point is that opposing the established system—moreover, in many countries of the world—absolutely openly, playing by its own rules and resorting to standard and well-known practices, as the tragically deceased Alexei did, can be very dangerous and ultimately unproductive. But in the modern world, it is possible and necessary to resort to alternative approaches that, in principle, do not involve direct confrontation.

As a good example, I would point to how a certain anonymous individual (or group of anonymous individuals) under the pseudonym Satoshi Nakamoto destroyed the “sacred” monopoly of stationary bandits (states) over money by creating Bitcoin. He was never reliably deanonymized, and his tool was designed so that even in the event of full deanonymization, or even the physical liquidation of the creator, it would not cease to exist and function, as it is decentralized. Meanwhile, the anonymous and state-uncontrollable payment methods and electronic currencies that existed before Bitcoin, such as E-gold and Liberty Reserve, were destroyed by the US government due to their centralized structure and the presence of specific, non-anonymous creators and managers, who ultimately received very long prison sentences.

Ideally, stationary bandits should not even be aware that someone is opposing them, and should not have the ability to track down those who are doing so. The methods of opposition should be extremely unconventional and non-traditional, most likely relying on modern technologies. Here, one could also mention current wars—with the popularization of modern drones, states have lost the ability to effectively destroy the production of high-tech weaponry when attacking someone. No matter how well-protected or hidden a large centralized military plant producing traditional weapons by traditional methods is, sooner or later it will be bombed. But with hundreds of small private enterprises producing thousands of drones a day and not united by any single management structure, absolutely nothing can be done. Such a modern, non-traditional approach to the production of high-tech weaponry is capable of providing protection even to those facing an enemy vastly superior in strength.

Exactly which methods can be proposed is for those who possess the necessary competence in a given field to decide. But we, within the framework of our project, can put forward one approach relying on science and modern technology. Understanding that the ability to commit intentional, planned, and targeted acts of violence without experiencing any internal repulsion or resistance is the result of an individual having a disorder—a dysfunction of the violence inhibition mechanism—makes clinical therapy of violent behavior possible using means that enhance the function of this mechanism. And in the event of a threat of violence from certain private individuals or representatives of some organized structure, it would be worth considering the creation of a combat version of such a biological solution. You can always find more details about the violence inhibitor concept in our materials.

I do not love and do not know how to write epitaphs

There is one negative aspect to Navalny’s death: a good man has died. But there could never have been a happy ending in his fairy tale.

Otherwise, alas, things have rather improved.

The Russian regime has lost the potential opportunity to use a well-known political prisoner as bargaining material or a tool for blackmail.

The Russian opposition has an additional reason to abandon the idea of peaceful protest. Some of its representatives, acting by inertia, will go out into the streets of Russian cities to publicly express their grief, face persecution, and leave the RF.

I have an additional reason to increase my efforts in writing a book on the theory of war.

Other political regimes may throw a bit more fuel onto the fire of war with the RF (it would be good if without new mindless sanctions against those Russians who are easier to reach, but here life rather forces one to be a pessimist).