Book about ancap: finished the chapter on agorism

Finished polishing the subject. In the course of the narrative, I often had to bite my tongue, because there was much that could be told about how we practice agorism in our Montellibero, but I promised to make the book as concise as possible, which means there is no room for lyrical digressions.

Each chapter about one approach or another to building ancap ended with a list of that approach’s shortcomings and a pointer to the fact that it is unable to lead to ancap. Now all that’s left for me is to summarize everything written, and after that, I can move on to editing while the trail is still hot.

How strongly the resistance to committing murder affects a person

Voluntarist, Bitarch

In 2011, US Air Force psychologists conducted a mental health screening of 600 combat drone operators. As it turned out, 42% of UAV operators reported moderate or severe stress, and 20% reported emotional exhaustion or burnout. A later study showed that drone operators suffered from the same levels of depression, anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder, alcohol abuse, and suicidal ideation as conventional combat crews. Many will immediately ask—why is this happening?

As far back as the 20th century, many military experts concluded that 98% of people experience strong internal resistance to committing murder, and only up to 2% of individuals with psychopathic predispositions do not. In analyzing the issue of modern warfare involving combat drones, it is important for us to pay attention to what these experts said about the factors influencing the ability to kill and the factors leading to psychological trauma on the battlefield. The conclusions drawn and listed in the works of Dave Grossman will be especially helpful to us in this regard.

Firstly, this example with combat drone operators confirms the conclusion that killing is the most traumatic experience for a human being. As Grossman writes, the contradiction between the necessity to kill and the inability to do so due to internal resistance traumatizes a soldier’s psyche more than any other difficulties of combat operations. And those soldiers who were still able to kill most often suffer for the rest of their lives after the war because of what they committed.

A drone operator does not experience cold, hunger, lack of sleep, physical injuries, the loss of comrades, the risk of dying at any moment, and many other things that an ordinary soldier faces in battle. The only thing that unites them is the necessity to kill. This, therefore, only proves the long-established conclusion that killing is absolutely unnatural for humans and is the most traumatic experience of all possible ones.

Secondly, although military experts of the past concluded that distancing allows one to bypass the resistance to killing, they apparently underestimated how strongly it is expressed in humans. Even for a UAV operator, who may be located on the other side of the planet from the combat operations, this resistance does not completely disappear. The mere awareness of committing a murder is enough to cause psychological trauma.

An analogy can be drawn with the trench warfare of the First World War, in which hand grenades proved to be psychologically effective weapons. A soldier simply threw a grenade toward the enemy trenches, and it was not necessary for him to directly observe the enemy for this or what his actions led to. However, if he did see the result of his actions, or even just heard it, for example in the form of the screams of enemy soldiers, it could already traumatize his psyche.

All of this shows us that as long as a human is fundamentally capable of realizing the fact of committing a murder, no means will make it an easy act for them. By the way, this also aligns with the assumption of the Violence Inhibition Mechanism (VIM) model. Although this mechanism is directly activated only when a person can observe the suffering of their victim, due to the process of conditioning (the formation of conditioned reflex reactions), its functioning from childhood develops the ability to experience a rejection reaction even at the mere thought of committing violence.

As we can see, one cannot underestimate how unnatural the act of killing is for a human being. Every mentally healthy individual possesses a violence inhibitor, the function of which cannot simply be bypassed or suppressed. Even if certain means and methods enable some people to commit murder, it still does not end well for them. Only a tiny percentage of psychopathic personalities are truly capable of easily committing murder.

Stéphane Molinier. Practical Anarchy. Chapter 17.

It’s been a while since I worked on the translation of Molynieux’s “Practical Anarchy,” but from time to time, even those texts that don’t receive donations need to be posted, otherwise the public forgets they exist.

In chapter 17, The Stateless Society: An Exploration of Alternatives, the author examines several groups of typical arguments put forward by supporters of the state in defense of the state’s right to exist, and for each group provides a brief justification of their invalidity. As usual, he maintains a brisk polemical style, but, of course, the orientation of the arguments toward a Western reader is evident.

As a reminder, I am continuing the projects to translate several books into Russian:

  1. Libertarianism by Eric Mack – 20 out of 23 chapters translated
  2. Practical Anarchy by Stephan Molynieux – 18 out of 29 chapters translated
  3. Legal Systems Very Different from Our Own by David Friedman – 9 out of 22 chapters translated

I am also about to finish writing my own book about ancap.

And all of this is much easier to work on when there are donations.

Rapists are not more successful in procreation

Voluntarist, Bitarch

There is a myth that more cruel and aggressive people should be more successful in reproduction, as this is an advantageous behavioral strategy. An example can be drawn from the research of anthropologist Napoleon Chagnon, according to which greater reproductive success compared to tribesmen of their own age is found among those men of the Yanomami indigenous people living in Brazil and Venezuela who commit murders. It is claimed that they have 2.5 times more wives and 3 times more children.

As Chagnon and some other researchers believe, the success of aggressive men in reproduction is the rule for primitive societies. According to their evolutionary logic, killers push their neighbors out of reproduction and have more offspring, meaning murder becomes a hereditary trait. Therefore, humans became born killers in the course of evolution. But if this conclusion is examined in more detail, it turns out that 6 arguments can be put forward against it:

  1. Computer simulations of evolutionary processes have shown that neither a warlike strategy (hawk), consisting of carrying out attacks, nor a timid strategy (dove), consisting of retreating during attacks, are as evolutionarily stable strategies as the “retaliator strategy,” where individuals behave non-aggressively but will still fight back in the event of an attack. Timid individuals cannot compete with aggressive individuals, but at the same time, aggressive individuals risk sustaining injuries in battles. Therefore, the mixed retaliator strategy is the most optimal.
  2. Data from animal behavior research shows that most intra-species aggression is non-lethal. Of course, in some situations, killing conspecifics can be beneficial, but in most cases, this is not the case. Accordingly, in the course of biological evolution, inhibitors of intra-species aggression are developed, preventing harm in battles.
  3. Military research has shown that the average healthy individual has strong internal resistance to committing murder. Only 1-2% of soldiers with sociopathic tendencies do not experience this in battle. There are also a number of evolutionary factors as to why such resistance is inherent in humans. As with animals, killing conspecifics is rarely a strategy encouraged by natural selection for humans.
  4. Humans possess the potential for competition, aggression, and even committing murder, and wars occur in many societies. However, examples of absolutely non-violent societies, such as the Semai and Paliyar peoples, show that humans are capable of living peacefully. This raises questions regarding the claim that murder is a natural trait of humans.
  5. Research on the Yanomami people has methodological problems. Firstly, anthropologist Brian Ferguson questioned the claim that killers and non-killers were of comparable age. Accordingly, the difference in the number of children may be explained by the difference in age of the studied individuals. Chagnon ignored this criticism. Secondly, examining Chagnon’s data, Ferguson concluded that even if killers had a reproductive advantage, it was nowhere near as large as 3 times. The criticism of Chagnon’s research does not end there; there are many other reasons why they may be methodologically unsound.
  6. Other studies demonstrate opposite results. For instance, a study of the Waorani people of Ecuador showed that zealous warriors who carry out raids on fellow tribesmen have lower reproductive success. They did not have more wives or children; moreover, their children were less likely to survive to reproductive age. As a result, warlike men proved to be not as individually fit as less aggressive men.

As we can see, a large amount of theoretical and empirical data shows that in various social circumstances, killers should have fewer children than non-killers. And the idea of murder as an evolutionarily advantageous strategy for humans faces many obstacles.

Which form of government is best to strive for under minarchism?

Levoberezhny

Minarchism is an extremely unstable state, where the cancerous tumor called the state has just been pushed into maximum remission by stripping it of as many functions and resources for their execution as possible, leaving only what simply cannot be taken away—either because officials resisted strongly, the people cannot understand how to manage without it, or something else.

Therefore, I understand the question roughly as follows: under which form of government will a minarchist state expand its powers most slowly? My answer: shareholder democracy. Historically, trading republics, such as Venice, were quite close to this method of management.

The point of this form of government is that the right to vote in the administration of the republic belongs to those who contribute to its functioning, and exactly to the extent to which they contribute. Modern technologies fully allow for quite complex voting with share packages, including options for delegating votes and revoking that delegation.

When people allocate their own money, they tend to maximize savings and are least inclined to give anyone the right to forcibly seize citizens’ money. This is precisely what makes them vigilantly monitor any potential abuses by authorized officials, which works more reliably than a simply formally drawn scheme of checks and balances.

One might wonder, how is this worse than a scheme with a benevolent dictator who unilaterally pays for all state functions out of their own pocket, providing state services to others? The problem is that everyone else must be guided by his sole conception of the common good, which can change unpredictably and rapidly. Simply compare the pace and amplitude of changes in the structures of Bitcoin and Ethereum.

At Montelibero, we are implementing exactly this form of government: both in the eponymous fund and in the land cooperative building the village. (These are two different entities with slightly different vote-counting mechanisms: in the village, we simply vote by square meters, and in the fund, a logarithmic formula for calculating vote weight currently applies so that no one can obtain a controlling interest.) So, I am not only reasoning theoretically about the best form of government, but I am also participating in the field testing of the one I consider to be the best.

Enrico Dandolo, Chairman of the Board of the Most Serene Republic of Venice

Is the deterrence of aggression linked to oxytocin and pro-social behavior?

Voluntarist, Bitarch

It is a well-known fact that the hormone oxytocin plays an important role in pro-social behavior. It promotes the formation of attachment between mother and child, pair bonding, disposes a person to trust and benevolence toward those they consider “their own,” helps establish relationships between people, and so on. The hormone vasopressin also plays an important role in pro-social behavior, including the formation of paternal love for children.

These hormones are often called regulators of aggression. It is believed that in intra-group relations, oxytocin promotes the establishment of altruism and non-violence, which unite and coordinate the actions of individual group members. Conversely, in the case of inter-group relations, this only increases aggressiveness, as a cohesive group is ready to fight more fiercely against other “alien” groups, toward whose members oxytocin does not dispose one to trust. This is often used to explain the occurrence of wars between different groups of people [1].

At the same time, based on the theory of the violence inhibition mechanism, in species where it is strongly expressed, including humans, the restraint of aggression extends to all intra-species relations. Nevertheless, the violence that does occur is explained by the presence of a small number of individuals in whom this mechanism is impaired. This conclusion is supported by many studies, including military ones. They show that most people experience strong resistance to harming others and committing murder. Even on the battlefield, this applies to the majority of soldiers, and only a minority of them constitute the driving force of war [2].

Having two such explanations for the nature of social and aggressive behavior, the question arises as to which one is correct, or if both are correct, how they relate to one another. Answering such a question is not so difficult if one looks at how the corresponding neurophysiological systems work and interact with each other.

Recall that the use of certain agonists of serotonin 1A and 1B receptors (drugs that activate them) led to the suppression of attacking aggression in animals, while not affecting defensive aggression or other forms of behavior and social communication. This result is completely consistent with the expected result of the work of a violence inhibitor, which speaks to its function as part of the serotonergic (5-HT) system.

It is interesting that the 5-HT system, including 1A and 1B receptors, is involved in the regulation of oxytocin and vasopressin secretion [3]. In one experiment, the use of a 1A receptor agonist in mice promoted not only the suppression of attacking aggression but also the emergence of pro-social behavior (close contact and grooming of a conspecific) due to oxytocin secretion. At the same time, the simultaneous administration of an oxytocin receptor antagonist (a drug that blocks it) did not reduce the anti-aggressive effect at all, but only suppressed the pro-social behavior. And administration together with a vasopressin receptor antagonist changed nothing at all [4].

It can be concluded that the regulation of aggression and the stimulation of pro-social behavior are functions performed by different neurophysiological systems. Moreover, the 5-HT system, responsible for the former, is capable of influencing the operation of oxytocin and vasopressin receptors, responsible for the latter, but not vice versa. This means that it is precisely the theory of the violence inhibition mechanism that explains the nature of aggression regulation, while oxytocin relates only to pro-social behavior. And the absence of such behavior in an individual—for example, when encountering a “stranger” (but a representative of their own species) or simply due to the impairment of the oxytocin receptor, while the violence inhibitor is still functioning—absolutely does not mean that they will be predisposed to a violent attack.

1. De Dreu C. K. W. et al. (2010). The Neuropeptide Oxytocin Regulates Parochial Altruism in Intergroup Conflict Among Humans;
2. Theory of Violence: https://antiviolence.io/ru;
3. Jørgensen, H., Riis, M., Knigge, U., Kjaer, A., & Warberg, J. (2003). Serotonin Receptors Involved in Vasopressin and Oxytocin Secretion;
4. Tan, O., Martin, L. J., & Bowen, M. T. (2020). Divergent pathways mediate 5-HT1A receptor agonist effects on close social interaction, grooming and aggressive behaviour in mice: Exploring the involvement of the oxytocin and vasopressin systems.

Finished writing the chapter on bit-coins in the ancap manual

The matter is gradually nearing completion. The book is almost ready in rough draft; later, I will polish it, adapting the text so that even a non-professional narrator can read it aloud without getting tripped up by tongue-twisting phrasing (I want to make an audiobook). For now, I present to you a freshly written chapter on the instrumental approach to building ancap. There are no historical studies on cypherpunks and such—just a very brief overview of why all this is needed, how it works, and why it doesn’t work very well.

Suicides among veterans or why war is unnatural for humans

Voluntarist, Bitarch

Some might argue that there have always been wars in human history, and therefore it is a completely natural phenomenon. Many arguments can be made as to why this is not the case, but one of the most telling is the prevalence of suicide among veterans. In September 2019, the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs published a report stating that at least 60,000 veterans committed suicide between 2008 and 2017. According to statistics, nearly two dozen veterans commit suicide every day in the US, and according to some claims, more Iraq War veterans have committed suicide than died on the battlefield. An extremely high suicide rate can also be observed among veterans of Afghanistan.

Moreover, it is not even necessary to take the US as an example. There is recent data that since November 2020, at least 26 Azerbaijani veterans of the second Karabakh war have committed suicide. In 2018, in the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, one of the representatives of the veterans’ affairs committee reported thousands of suicides among participants in the battles in Donbas. As for Russia, there are data that in 2004, more than 1,000 suicide attempts were recorded among those who had been to Chechnya. Surely, the list of suicides among veterans even only in the countries and conflicts we have considered is far from over. And the list of psychologically traumatized veterans who did not decide to commit suicide will be dozens of times larger. And it is frightening to imagine how many psychiatric losses, besides the direct cases of death in battle, await us on both sides after the end of the military conflict between Russia and Ukraine.

Military experts have long known that the average healthy individual possesses a strong internal resistance to killing, and only less than 2% of people are able to do it easily. But in war, a person is forced to try to suppress their violence inhibitor and commit killings, because otherwise they will not be able to cope with the task at hand, will fail their comrades, and will ultimately contribute to defeat in battle. These two contradictory factors—the necessity to kill and the inability to kill—together are the main cause of psychological trauma on the battlefield. Even among those who were able to kill in war, such traumas are not uncommon, because after realizing what they have done, they cannot come to terms with it and suffer for the rest of their lives. Definitely, war is absolutely unnatural for human beings.

What children’s rights does anarcho-capitalism provide for?

Can parents commit an act of aggression against their children, or do they have full ownership rights over their child?

Is it an act of aggression against one’s child to stop feeding them, condemning them to death by starvation? Probably not, but if so, from what age to what age?

If parents have full ownership rights over a child, does this ever end, and if so, at what age does a person gain the ability to become a full member of society and sign the NAP?

Is it possible to intentionally kill one’s own child without violating the NAP?

Is selling one’s own child into sexual slavery aggression?

From what age are children allowed to work and consume alcohol/substances?

Andrey Fridges

The author of the question prefaced it with a quote from Rothbard’s The Ethics of Liberty about how a free market for children should be developed in a free society (I omitted this fragment), and it seems appropriate to me to supplement this deontologist with the utilitarian Friedman, who in his The Machinery of Freedom dedicated one entire chapter to the rights of children.

Now, I will express my own opinion on the specific questions asked. To start, of course, I suggest re-reading the chapter of my ancap manual that I have to refer to most often—the one on conflicts, morality, and law.

A child, being a human, possesses self-ownership from a libertarian point of view, and therefore the NAP is fully applicable to them—no one has the right to initiate violence with impunity. If a parent acts against the interests of their child, there is clearly a conflict between them. Libertarian morality dictates intervention in a conflict on the side of justice. Therefore, any third-party libertarian, driven by their own morality, will attempt to delve into the observed conflict between parent and child to determine which position is more just.

Justice, I remind you, is the feeling of proportionality between the damage caused and the value of the subject of the conflict. Therefore, a third-party adult, putting themselves in the place of the damage being caused to the child and comparing it with how valuable they perceive the subject of the conflict between the child and parent to be, may quite possibly conclude that the child should be protected.

Not feeding a child is not violence. But violence is preventing them from obtaining food, or preventing others from feeding the child.

Selling the rights to preferential guardianship over a child (that is, parental rights themselves) is not violence. If the buyer turns the child into a sexual slave, that would be violence.

Allowing a child to be hired for work or consume harmful substances is not violence. But violence is forcing them to work under a stick or imposing harmful substances upon them.

In all these cases, the guardian finds themselves in a situation where they can cause indirect harm to the child without direct violence. To what extent compensation for indirect harm can be recovered is impossible to predict under ancap conditions (decentralization of law plus the market); a unique solution may be found for every conflict, or a standard one may be consistently adopted if it generally satisfies everyone.

In short: here are the principles, and from there, decide for yourselves; books of ready-made recipes have some value, but they should not be perceived as dogma.