Balance of Violence Potential

Balance of Violence Potential (BVP), or more accurately, the uniform distribution of violence potential, is a certain state in society where any person is capable of inflicting unacceptable damage on another in a local clash. For simplicity, BVP can be viewed as maximum universal armament in society, where absolutely every resident of a given territory possesses a weapon for personal self-defense, for example, a pistol or even such ersatz weaponry as a blinding laser or a poison dart, preferably several units, so that it would be impossible to disarm anyone. It is assumed that residents of this territory have the opportunity (or rather an obligation in the form of a cultural norm) to possess weapons based on their physiological capabilities without any legal barriers (for example, age, citizenship, “criminal records” for activities undesirable from the state’s point of view) and financial need (volunteers and high-tech corporations will help the poor obtain weapons for free, just as vaccination is currently helped in poor countries, since this is profitable for them as well).

Why is BVP needed? To eradicate physical violence from society. This will allow for a significant increase in the quality of life and welfare of the population, eliminate tyranny of both the stationary bandit (the state) and the criminal mafia and touring bandits, and allow scientific and technical progress to develop peacefully, without fearing a global catastrophe.

By what means will BVP reduce/eradicate violence? In a multitude of different ways:

1) Classical deterrence doctrine (“deterrence by punishment”) against rational aggressors. Knowing that the victim of violence can inflict unacceptable damage on the aggressor, including even killing them, the aggressor will think carefully and decide that the benefit from violence will be less than the costs and will ultimately renounce violence.

There is a good example of such a model in the wild — porcupines. Cheetahs also frequently live in porcupine habitats, and they are hundreds of times superior in physical strength. But here is the surprising part: a cheetah can theoretically maul and eat a porcupine, but practically never does. There are occasional stupid individuals who decide to do so, but as a result, they either die or sustain such injuries that they never dare to try again.

2) Deterrence through denial (“deterrence by denial”) against invader states. The authorities of such a state set a specific goal — to conquer a territory and subjugate its residents. An aggressor can, of course, drop a nuclear bomb, but radioactive land without residents is worth absolutely nothing. As for the political elite of the aggressor, this is the end, because their own population will tear them to pieces for such an act. It would also create a dangerous precedent for the permissibility of using WMDs against civilians and legitimize the creation of strategic deterrent weapons by everyone capable of doing so (even now, a biohacker student is capable of multiplying a deadly virus and does not do so only for moral reasons).

3) The impossibility of creating and maintaining a violently hierarchical structure in a society with BVP. In such a society, the use of violence locally between people becomes unprofitable; accordingly, it is impossible to create and maintain a larger hierarchy of dominance (for example, a state) through the sequential accumulation of resources in the format of a “military hegemon.”

For example, an aggressor Vasya, having only a pistol, attacks Petya to use his resources to buy a Kalashnikov assault rifle. With it, he can attack Sasha with doubled force, buying a tank with the resources taken from him. Using this tank, he can attack billionaire Vanya with tripled force, who can even afford serious security, and use the obtained resources to hire a large army to conquer the entire country. But in the case of universal armament (uniform BVP), Vasya would be destroyed at the very beginning of his bloody path.

Imagine what would have happened if “little aliens” in the 1960s had arranged a “rain of pistols” over St. Petersburg? A teenager Pynya, who was prone to violence from birth, would with a probability close to 100% have died in a clash the next day, and the question of how to deal with him now would simply not be on the agenda.

4) Forcing natural selection that removes those prone to violence from the population. Analyzing many different species, biologist Konrad Lorenz found an interesting pattern — in animal species with strong innate armament (for example, hedgehogs, poisonous snakes, and insects) that allows them to very effectively inflict unacceptable damage on any opponent in a clash, an innate intra-species morality of non-aggression developed (more precisely — an instinct of aversion to initiating physical violence against a member of their own species), because otherwise the survival of the species would be under threat. This happened as a result of the most violence-prone individuals being destroyed during acts of aggression and thus failing to produce offspring. In humans, such a morality of non-aggression did not develop because humans are not a naturally heavily armed species; the mortality of fights with bare fists without the use of any additional means is very low, therefore there was no pressure from natural selection to develop this trait. More precisely, such a neurobiological mechanism also exists in the species homo sapiens, but in a very weak form. But if BVP is leveled in society, the pressure of natural selection will strengthen it in homo sapiens to the level of heavily armed species, since carriers of gene variants that cause less aversion to the initiation of violence in humans will be removed from the population before they even have a chance to pass them to the next generation.

Bitarch

Mechanics of Freedom, Chapter 66

That’s it, I’m publishing the last chapter of The Mechanics of Freedom, Welcome to the Future, hooray! Here, Friedman discusses what ensures digital privacy and what hinders its widespread adoption, why anonymous altcoins provide less anonymity than bitcoin mixers, and touches upon a topic I raised in Digital Identity — that it doesn’t matter how strong your ciphers are if the observer is omnipresent.

All I have left is to edit and post the appendices. Next, I’ll need to go through the entire text to make final corrections — the translation took over a year, so some stylistic inconsistency is inevitable for now. Then, I’ll need to format the text for e-books as well as for print. After that, I’ll upload all this wealth to the website, send it to Friedman, and offer the print version to both the DPRs and the Tea Club — in short, let it spread as widely as possible, for all our joy.

To make the joy complete, you can throw me an encouraging portion of bitcoins. Oh, right, I mustn’t forget to include an acknowledgments page in the finished book: for those who sent donations, those who translated, and the person who obtained the full version of the text from the author — in short, let no one be left out.

Belarus 4

This is my fourth text about Belarus (others can be found via the hashtag ), and this time it was prompted by watching a conversation between Mikhail Svetov, Roman Popkov, and Elena Borovskaya, as well as Roman’s post summarizing the stream on his channel.

Roman Popkov’s account of the current state of Belarusian civil society was very informative and explained why things are going the way they are, but right now I want to talk about something else.

During the conversation, Roman reproached “Moskals” for their excessively technological mindset. Ponasenkov took the brunt of it with his Die erste Kolonne marschiert, die zweite Kolonne marschiert, but Svetov, who agreed with Ponasenkov, also got hit. I, for one, although I live separated from Moscow by a considerable distance and the Ural range, am still one of those very same “Moskals,” and therefore I also have a purely technological approach to this political science problem: how to ensure the transit from an illegitimate dictatorship to a transitional government, constitutional reform, and a new legitimate government. And I see exactly two options.

Option one. Do you want it to be like in Ukraine?

If the dictator previously had enough strength to weed out combat organizations (hello to Roman Popkov and his NBP) by the root, then now, with constant street protests occurring, it is quite easy to disguise combat coordination training as episodic spontaneous coordination. Tens of thousands of people daily search for the most effective ways to exhaust the opponent’s resources, get to know each other, find out what everyone is capable of, and if the degree of anger continues to rise, then at some point the hundreds of corpses mentioned by Roman will stop seeming like a serious restriction on the path to overthrowing the dictatorship.

Of course, they don’t charge head-on toward administrative buildings, but, as we saw in Ukraine, they seize military warehouses and armories in police stations. After that, a transition to the hot phase of street fighting is inevitable, even if no one is injured during the seizure of weapons. And street fighting will inevitably end with the overthrow of the dictator.

Option two. What is the name of the President of Switzerland?

What follows is a fantasy story; do not take it as a forecast.

Tikhanovskaya arrives for Biden’s inauguration. This is an excellent pretext to discuss exactly how to overthrow Lukashenko. The invasion option is dismissed, and a cheaper one is proposed. Lukashenko is placed on an international wanted list, and a serious reward by Belarusian standards is set for his capture, dead or alive—say, a conventional hundred million dollars. Simultaneously, a second very important person enters the fray; his name is Guy Parmelin. He is the Vice President of the Swiss Confederation, who by the time of Biden’s inauguration will be the new president (hello to Mikhail Svetov and his constant rhetorical question about the name of the President of Switzerland). Switzerland is a neutral country with a very stable political system. Only it can give Lukashenko a guarantee of lifelong political asylum (Russia or the USA cannot).

That’s it; now we start the clock and watch to see what happens first: one of Lukashenko’s guards presents his head and demands the reward—or Lukashenko seeks guarantees from Mr. Parmelin and leaves the country immediately after they are confirmed.

Readings of Adam Smith, recording

While the Adam Smith Readings were taking place, I was commenting on them via text on Telegram and Facebook, but now the organizers have uploaded the final recordings to their YouTube channel, so those interested can watch specific lectures targetedly rather than watching a continuous recording of the broadcast.

Personally, I found the lectures by Lyudmila Petranovskaya on the ethical aspects of COVID discussions, as well as Evgeny Varshaver’s on the integration of migrants, to be the most interesting. Let me know in the comments what you enjoyed.

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLuhWCrj1ep6EW8b7AG13bqnFNMHho-Gjz

In defense of Linux

Yesterday, I published a post describing my modest user experience installing a single program on Linux. The verdict was that for most people, even if they are libertarians through and through, convenience in the here and now can easily prove more important than abstract ideals. This is true in far more cases than just when choosing between a graphical interface and a console. In the same way, people neglect to carry means of self-defense, don’t set passwords on their phones, and have sex without a condom.

Naturally, the post sparked a lot of debate, because the war between adherents of different approaches to interacting with computers has dragged on since deep antiquity. And, as I understand it, every revival of this eternal bickering always consists of at least two posts: the first condemning Linux, and the second defending it. Today is time for the second.

I installed a version of Linux that was positioned to me as being quite close to Windows in terms of interface. It installed easily and effortlessly. All typical applications, such as office suites, browsers, Telegram, or password managers, are installed without any console via the graphical shell. If my task were to move all my daily work to open-source software, I would move to Linux without any problems and wouldn’t notice much of a difference. Meanwhile, there are many atypical tasks for which I would need the help of someone with deeper system knowledge even under Windows.

The world is full of technically complex devices that no one has the slightest need to study thoroughly. The magic of the division of labor lies in the fact that everyone focuses on what they have a relative advantage in. Every object has its nuances, and some people specialize in them to increase their value. But at the same time, for the average user, it generally makes no difference which system they use to perform most of their tasks; any will do.

So, I will clarify my answer from yesterday to the question of why libertarians don’t use open-source software. Yes, they use what is convenient, but often a large part of that convenience boils down to the network effect. If advertisements for computer technician services mentioned not the setup of Windows and installation of antivirus, but the selection of a Linux distribution and system configuration for the user’s tasks; if information on government resources were stored in odt rather than docx; if hardware Bitcoin wallets were sold in mobile phone stores—that would be clear evidence of the network effect working in favor of open-source software and decentralized money.

What is needed for libertarians to use open-source software? Simply to start using open-source software.

This post was written on Linux, and future ones will be written on it as well. There is no reason to delay adopting useful habits.

Useful habits

Open source, libertarianism, and laziness

Why do libertarians dislike talking about open-source software and its advantages? Shouldn’t a libertarian use only free software (Linux instead of Windows and MacOS, LineageOS instead of Android and iOS) if they respect their own freedom and privacy? Free software helps protect against surveillance by the state and corporations—it allows one to achieve true freedom. Or do most libertarians not respect their own privacy? If it is too difficult to understand all the technical intricacies, why not pay others to create accessible programs and educational materials?

Richard Stallman

Someone recently tried to teach me how to write Telegram bots. For some reason, this meant I had to install Linux. The system was installed without any problems, but then the “dancing with a tambourine” began. Let’s install Python. Open the console, write this specific incantation. Did it work? Come on, send a screenshot. Aha, a correction, write this incantation instead. Now let’s install these libraries. Write this incantation. That’s it, launch PyCharm. Why not from a shortcut on the desktop? Why must even such an elementary action be done from the console? And now in PyCharm, open its internal console and write this incantation there to install the libraries. Wait, we already installed them! It doesn’t matter, they need to be installed locally for each project. And don’t forget to select the interpreter. I’m already in PyCharm; it’s an IDE, why do I need ten interpreters to choose from? What prevents them from making one by default and ten optional ones for the masochists? Who taught you UX?..

I have nothing against open-source software or content. I went to Wikipedia and made edits to the article about David Friedman. Five minutes—and millions of Russian-speaking users get access to up-to-date information. Spontaneous orders are power! But if handmade clothing is expensive and uncomfortable, then only historical reenactors will wear it. If an open-source OS requires far more effort for simple things than a proprietary one, then only geeks obsessed with security will use it.

Whoever steals the Windows source code from Microsoft and posts it in the public domain on some maximally decentralized platform will do humanity a huge favor. Because this system quite deservedly holds its market share—even despite being proprietary and spying on the user. I have written repeatedly that we are already ready to live in conditions of “new sincerity,” where everyone can and has the full moral right to spy on everyone else, so the system’s spying is not perceived as something terrible—as long as it doesn’t steal your money or snitch on you to the Investigative Committee (and people stay on VKontakte even knowing that it snitches on users). There are many examples of software that was proprietary for some time and then was released into the public domain, and thereafter is developed by the community. And obviously, the weaker the state protection granted to IT giants, the more often this will happen.

I had never heard of Lineage OS, so I looked it up, and it turned out that my phone model is not supported. So, when I change my phone, I’ll buy one with this factor in mind (if supported models don’t turn out to be disproportionately expensive), and then we’ll see. I hope it will be more like the Wikipedia experience than the Linux one.

Using open-source software is like being a vegan. If you live in India, it’s no problem; there’s plenty of delicious vegan food everywhere. If you’re in Russia, you pointlessly condemn yourself to a more expensive life of lower quality for the sake of certain ethical principles. The more these principles mean to you, the greater the sacrifices you will make to follow them. Free software is cool, but software that is convenient to use is much cooler for the vast majority. The market has decided.

Forgive me…

Balance of Violence. A new video from Libertarian Band.

Libertarian Band has released the fourth video from the series on the balance of violence potential. Since the video is titled Balance of Violence, it is not hard to guess that it occupies a central position in the series.

The key idea in the video is that the balance of violence potential is ensured not only by possibly equal armament—this is unattainable, as players with more resources will easily win an arms race. The factor of solidarity is far more important. The willingness to not allow violence to be used not only against oneself, but also against others—if one can speak of a silver bullet regarding the construction of a non-violent society—then this is the closest candidate.

Of course, the video is not reduced to this single thought; I won’t retell it in full, watch it for yourself. The technical quality of the video continues to grow, but don’t forget to feed the studio with your donations. A critical dependence on one large sponsor strongly disrupts the balance of the potential for independence in decisions, if one may put it that way.

Philipp Bagus. In Defense of Deflation.

The Telegram channel BITCOIN TRANSLATED has published a translation of Philipp Bagus’s book The Defense of Deflation (as usual, I have moved the text to my own site to avoid broken links). The translator is Sergey Soltys. I haven’t read the book yet; once I do, I will post a review. But I shouldn’t delay your access to the reading just because I haven’t formed an opinion on the text yet. Usually, if libertarians translate something on their own and put it in the public domain, it means they consider the work to be worth it.

What to do with digital data under ancap? What will the privacy policy be in minarchism?

In our new world, data has turned into a very profitable commodity traded by states, companies, hackers, and anyone else who feels like it! Could they all possibly give up this resource at once, even if you were to cut the state out by the roots? Moreover, people mostly don’t care about their personal data when visiting websites, downloading games, apps, or TikToks. In other words, it’s a kind of exchange of one’s data for convenience/benefits. I don’t think anyone’s property rights are being violated in this case. What do you think?

P.S. This question occurred to me while I was downloading a certain hyped-up Chinese game (those who know, know what I’m talking about). They wrote it right there: that you agree to let them use your account info for their own purposes. In other words, in simple language understandable to a human, and not like in other apps where everything is blurred and vague, explained as if saying, “we aren’t stealing from you, but we’ll take it somehow, and it’s better if you don’t think about it at all, ciao!”

Anal Magician

I would like to take this question as an opportunity to recommend to the reader an article in a channel with the immodest name without compromises, but with a surprisingly modest number of subscribers. However, the text of the article itself is posted on VKontakte, where the author has an order of magnitude more subscribers. There, a particular take interested me.

If one blindly honors the text of a contract with all its squiggles, reservations, and footnotes in tiny print, then the service provider has an economic incentive to cushion their own fall in the text of the agreement: the consumer will not look into the details, but the text of the agreement will significantly restrict them. However, the details of the agreement that are in plain sight must be made more attractive to the client because of competition.

But if we consider only that which was explicitly stated during the conclusion of the agreement as the contract, and treat all implicit nuances that were not discussed as merely unilateral good wishes—then an economic incentive appears to make contracts short and clear, so that the process of concluding the agreement is not burdensome for the buyer, otherwise they will go to another provider.

As we can see from the example you provided, when there is no need for legal hair-splitting, lawyers quickly switch to human language and state directly what rights they reserve. And, as we see from your reaction, the client tends to approve of such honesty. Meanwhile, it is unlikely that you would be so lenient toward a stated intention in a contract by the game developers, for example, to withdraw money from all your bank accounts or bitcoin wallets that the company manages to access. Even though, it would seem, this is also just a matter of access to data.

We live in an increasingly transparent world, which, moreover, will soon be filled with a large number of fakes indistinguishable from reality. Legal protection of personal data, privacy protection of personal life, private keys and passwords—all these are rearguard actions before full capitulation. What to do after capitulation? I wrote about this in one of my old posts titled Digital Identity.

The future is shaky, but I have a feeling that our generation has already accepted the new rules of the game in advance and isn’t particularly worried about it. As for those who, out of habit, will want to hide something, they are doomed to occasionally find themselves in an embarrassing position. Let’s wish them not to get too nervous over such blunders.

I apologize for not answering the direct question about what color underwear we will wear under ancap, and what style under minarchism. What can be done, if we will be going without underwear.

David Friedman. Legal Systems Strongly Differing from Ours. The Amish.

After a long break, Vladimir Zolotorev has published another chapter of the translation of David Friedman’s book Legal Systems Very Different from Our Own. In total, four chapters have been translated out of order as of today. Today’s is dedicated to the legal system of the Amish, who are beloved by Mikhail Svetov.

From the text, it is evident that these downshifters are sympathetic not only to many Americans, but also to Friedman himself. I wonder if they are currently facing problems because of their support for Trump…

The English original was posted on my website around the end of August. The same fate awaits the translation as it is published on mises.in.ua. Usually, corrections of minor flaws are made to the translation, but overall there is not much difference whether to read it on my site or Vladimir’s.